Marx was a Jew, both his parents were born Jewish, end of story, regardless how many bogus articles you produce by other Jews bemoaning the point he wasn't,
You said none would say otherwise.
The Wiki article even says his parents "converted" to escape "antisemitism", so he was in effect still of Jewish blood and most likely a Marrano Christian at that. Why do you continue to go down this road of denial that the father of Communism was not a Jew when the whole world except you and a few on this forum know this?
I don’t deny that he might be classed ethnically as a Jew. But that was my point. I was asking you about this and you insisted that his Jewishness was as defined as other Jews, not as the Nazis would have; by race.
His Jewishness ended when he himself became an atheist; he even declared himself anti-Jewish (religion).
That’s just part of your confused argument. You want to deny you’re following the racist stereo-type of the Nazis – and then you revert to a position that he’s always a Jew!
I haven’t even begun to tear apart your non-sequitur linking Judaism to Communism, because as practiced by Stalin it’s a very different form of Communism from Marxism.
I am a socialist. I have my socialism based on Christianity. I have a friend who’s an atheist and a Trotskyist. He would argue against that form of Communism in the Soviet Union under Stalin – Germany’s former friend, is based on
a) Judaism, or;
No, I said there was a Communist threat in Europe and Germany in particular during the Nazi rise to power and the build-up before the war and many Jews were influential with them as well as anti-German feeling since they were beginning to have Nationalist leanings and many Zionist Jews were tied in to the internationalist bankers that were trying to manipulate the German markets.
These same Communists that the Nazis signed a treaty with?
Even before the Nazis came to power the Communist government in Russia was allowing Germans to train in their clandestine build-up of their armed forces
Believe me, it wasn't just the "Jews" that were attacking Germany at the time, the Germans were still trying to recover from a world war that they neither wanted or started and never really surrendered but had to bear the burden for that crushed them as a people and nation.
The silliness of this is that Jews fought FOR Germany in World War One, but were excluded by racism
The German Nationalists fought back against not just the Jewish Communists but all sorts of Leftists, liberals, Democrats, Western usurpers, etc. they were trying to establish a Germany for Germans first and believed in a labor-backed economy, not Internationalist bankers cre4ating money out of nothing and loading Germany with insurmountable debt that they would never pay off, like we;re dealing with in this country today, like they're dealing with in Europe as well. There's a lot more to the war than just "hitler was evil" and killed a lot of Jews. Yea, I know, I get it already. so let's start from the beginning like I was trying to answer the OP about WHY Hitler "hated" the Jews. Let's try and stay on topic and not go on salivating rants about the holoco$t or how much of a Nazi "sympathizer" I am.
And now you’re back to justifying Hitler. You keep putting on record this stream of self-contradictory posts
Are you able to critically think for yourself or are you just gonna just shoot off a thousand posts in a row about how many Jews those evil ol nazis killed? a lot of of people died in that war, millions and millions of Asians that you holocausters barely even mention, It's a tragedy on all ends. But i'm not here to discuss why each and every soul was lost on a war that wasn't good for anyone's interests.
That’s a further non-sequitur.
“The holocausters barely mention” – a Jewish group dedicated to mentioning how many died in the Holocaust are indeed not going to mention how many died from another side. I look at pictures of the Vietnam memorial in Washington, and it’s full of the names of American servicemen. No Vietnamese communist names are recorded. We Australians were you allies. I don’t see Australians mentioned. I could rant “Americans barely mention others killed” too! But it’s silly. It’s ‘normal’ for a memorial to one thing doesn’t deal with other things.
Let's hear from you, why Hitler hated the Jews, that's it.
I already answered this – he was insane. I did this very succinctly. Perhaps you missed it?