Orthodoxy in DIXIE
By Father Joseph Huneycutt
I'm a Southerner. I was born and reared a Southern Baptist; educated
as an Episcopalian, and converted to Orthodox Christianity a decade
ago. Since then, I've been struggling to be Orthodox. As a missionary
priest, I've also struggled to bring others to Orthodoxy in the
South. More than anything, I've learned that I have a lot to learn.
I've also concluded that Orthodoxy, in its plethora of jurisdictions,
will have to learn some things, appreciate some things, about
Southern Culture before ever being truly successful in bringing
Southerners to the Faith.
I was reared in a small town near Charlotte, North Carolina. Growing
up, I never met a Jew, much less a Muslim. Lutherans were rare enough
in my hometown, much less Roman Catholics. Basically, we were
Baptists and Methodists, blacks and whites. I'd never even heard of
Orthodox Christianity until I was on my way to the Episcopal seminary
in the 1980's. Come to think of it, I'll bet most folks in my
hometown still have never heard of Orthodoxy.
No Orthodox jurisdiction ever sent missionaries to the South. Most
Converts have stumbled upon the Faith only after many years of
searching. If this were different, perhaps more progress would be
apparent in bridging the gap between East and South. Like St Innocent
who helped convert the natives of Alaska by "Incarnating" their
native faith thereby bringing them to Christ, would that someone had
intentionally helped the South to grow out of its native
Protestantism into the fullness of the Christian Faith. Instead, many
of the "ethnic churches" resemble Protestant churches with icons and
the assimilation, at least with church practices, has moved away from
traditional Orthodox practice toward Protestant norms. Such a vacuum
allows Converts to flounder toward the Kingdom while accumulating
various practices from the smorgasbord of Orthodoxy in America. It
also lends itself to parish and/or jurisdiction hopping in hopes of
finding the fittest vessel, the most correct iconography, the willing
I have heard that the seminaries in Russia are bursting with future
priests. We have a priest shortage in America, they may soon have a
glut in Russia. It wouldn't surprise me if they sent some of those
men to this country to evangelize. That would certainly wake us from
our jurisdictional squabbling and anti-Christian stupor! Maybe our
constant judging and nitpicking would be tempered by some honest to
Face it, the smorgasbord of Orthodox jurisdictions makes absolutely
no sense to most Converts. Finding the True Faith is encumbered by
also finding a dozen administrative bodies claiming to be really it!
I was once told by a monk "All monks are in communion with each
other." Though said in jest, very much like a tightly knit ethnic
community which fellowships within its own ethnic world, the same can
be said of Converts -- the majority of which are in the South.
We Southerners have many weaknesses. Paramount is our ingratiating
spirit. We deliberately set out to gain others' favour by winsome
actions. Hopelessly people-pleasing we are! Being "cut from this
cloth," we also have a weakness for taking a man at his word. If you
tell us that you're going to do something, more often than not, we
expect you'll do it. If you don't, there's a good chance that you'll
lose our trust, permanently. This behaviour will differ between
Southerners and Southerners and Southerners and Outsiders. Like any
ethnic group, we trust our own a while longer. Yet, to a Southerner,
duplicity appears rampant in American Orthodoxy. Arabs, Russians, and
other cultures are accustomed to hubris and other blustering within
daily discourse. In the South, we expect it of politicians. We
discourage it in decent folks. Integrity, in the South, is expected
of church leaders. Having found the True Faith we're confused by
contradictory words and actions which often emanate from the various
When I first became Orthodox in the Antiochian jurisdiction, someone
suggested that I read a book entitled "The Arab Mind" to get a sense
of my newly adopted church culture. The book claimed that, in Arabic,
the root word for eloquence and exaggeration is the same. An Arab may
exaggerate to show machismo. For instance, a man may shout across a
street corner to another "I hate you." The other man replies, "I not
only hate you, I'm going to kill you!" The man retorts "I'm going to
kill you and your family!" Etc. These same men may later be found
sharing a friendly meal together. Words fail me in describing how
this same dialogue might have ended in the South. Put it this way,
funeral processions still stall traffic in these parts.
Contrary to outsiders' perceptions, Southerners do not put on airs.
Though we may be hospitable, friendly, and civil, what you see is
what you get. If we share openly with you, it means we trust you.
Once you break that trust, it may be irreparable. All are welcomed
here. Yet, we are easily offended. If offended, the offending party
will be cut off till reparation. Our people-pleasing nature lends
itself to over-sensitivity. It just comes with the territory. In the
South, admiration comes easy, respect is earned over time.
Like all those outside Paradise, Southerners gossip. In a region
where being idle is considered a virtue, idle talk ain't far behind!
I don't mean the kind of vindictive gossip popularized by Soap Operas
and other media. (Though we have that too.) Rather, Southerners carry
on conversations in a way that others might view as gossiping. And,
God help us, at times it is. Yet, often this is a manner of couching
subjects within an engaging tale. It's the way we talk around here.
Southerners are self-effacing. We can take criticism if it's properly
couched in civility and/or humour. For us, if direct confrontation is
necessary, things have already gone too far! Sometimes our neighbors
to the North skip all the niceties and cut right to the chase.
(Northern aggression continues.) And, since all the Orthodox
jurisdictions hail from a different culture with the "home offices"
up North, this element of cultural war persists within church
dynamics. Brutal honesty is not only unwelcome but most often
rejected in the South.
Before attending my first gathering of Clergy and Church Wardens in
the Russian Church, I was asked about the nature and agenda of the
meeting. I said, "Well, they'll probably argue and yell at each other
for a few hours and then we'll have lunch. After lunch, they'll argue
and yell some more then we'll kiss each other goodbye and go home."
I'm no prophet, but boy was I ever on the mark with that prediction!
In such a setting you can recognize the Southerner -- he's the one
with his mouth shut. If asked, were he honest, he'd say "I think you
all are crazy." But, "don't ask, don't tell" has always been policy
where I'm from. Being slightly dishonest in the name of civility is
considered a virtue.
You yell at a Southerner and it may have eternal consequences. When
we speak, all that's required of you is to listen politely until it's
your turn. We don't take kindly yelling, interruption, jeering, or
public ridicule. We may not break bread with you until there's
resolution. You don't have to agree, mind you. But, you must behave
in such a way that assures civil discussion and debate. It may be
that we take things personally. But, we operate on the assumption
that you do to. Therefore, quite selfishly, the Golden Rule applies
no matter what your rank or station.
Northerners are most often defined by their family's nation of
origin. This type of identification is foreign to the South. Here,
folks are identified by their family name and/or their religious
affiliation. I've often heard Northerners speak of someone as being
Italian, Ukrainian, German, etc. Along with this description is the
implied religion of those being described (Roman Catholic, Orthodox,
Lutheran, etc). This is not the case in the South. Here, folks are
defined by their religion: Baptist, Episcopalian, Methodist,
Charismatic. So it is that Northern Orthodox are often amazed that
Christians would intentionally convert to Eastern Orthodoxy. What an
idea! Can you convert from Italian to German?
Folks in the rural South usually attend the church nearest their
home. In the country, you'll find mostly Baptists, Methodists, and
Pentecostals. Towns will have Presbyterian and Episcopalian churches.
And, here and there, you'll find Lutheran pockets and an occasional
Roman Catholic church. Latins and Lutherans may have a bit of a
drive or live within a "family burb." However, Presbyterian and
especially Episcopalian churches are populated with many who
have "worked their way up" to that denomination. Your particular
brand of Christianity may be a status symbol in the South.
Unfortunately, viewed from such binoculars, Orthodoxy can seem a step
down. Forgive me, but to a proper Episcopalian, Orthodoxy can seem
down right barbaric!
When expected, don't be surprised if a Southerner shows up early and
leaves late. We don't understand "Orthodox People Time." If you tell
a Southerner that something starts at 6:00 pm, he'll most likely
arrive at 5:45. We don't want to miss a thing! We're not only
unaccustomed to the Orthodox habit of being late, we find it rude and
uncivilized. Also, Southerners usually don't leave without saying
Goodbye, many times. This process of departing may take 30 minutes or
Southern culture is, at least, as relevant as other forms of
ethnicity -- whether "Orthodox" or not. We Converts appreciate the
foods and festivities of our adopted culture. But, must we discard
our norms and ways and replace them with those of traditionally
Orthodox lands? Fund raising's fine, but what about tithing? Lamb's
good, but so is pork barbecue. Pascha and kollich is festive, but
that first bite of pecan pie is just as heavenly. Can such Southern
gatherings as Mother's Day, Thanksgiving, family reunions, BBQs, and
oyster roasts be "baptized" into Orthodoxy? It's too early to tell.
Orthodoxy is new to the South. And it's yet to be seen whether the
two can melt into one God-pleasing flavor.
Converts have lots of extended family and friends that remain
Protestant. Thus, most find themselves in awkward situations.
Wednesdays and Fridays may not be as difficult to negotiate as is the
Peter & Paul Fast or fasting for Easter and Christmas. I baptized a
man who, for years, had hosted the family pig-picking on July 4th. Of
course, that's often a fast day. But that was his one big family
obligation. I remember a couple that I'd chrismated and had moved
away. The next major fast to come along, I called to see how they
were doing. They, in jest I suppose, replied "Oh, we're doing fine.
We're just eating over at our [non-Orthodox] friends' each evening!"
The pendulum may swing otherwise. You've seen them: the "Orthodox
Taliban." The man grows long hair and beard, forgets how to smile.
The woman covers herself from head to toe -- her modesty smothers her
dignity. They both stop bathing. There's no visible joy in their
life. Their wrists are covered with wool knots. They eat only
broccoli; tofu is reserved for feast days. They begin shopping for a
home -- preferably a tent or a lean-to -- out in the woods, sans the
burden of electricity. These things may not be harmful in and of
themselves. Yet oftentimes, when Converts confuse such "asceticism"
with Orthodoxy, it can have dire results.
Through Catechism, reading of the Fathers, and other instruction,
Converts fashion an ideal Orthodoxy toward which to struggle. Then,
they might get to know some of the "Cradle Orthodox" only to be
turned off. This can develop into a dichotomy leading to
judgmentalism, Pharisee-ism, and a sort of Convert-Superior-Orthodoxy
which is, needless to say, far from the ideal! We must all struggle
toward the ideal in humility. Thanks to the lackadaisical piety of
some Cradles, this can present a great challenge. To the eyes of the
beginner, many Cradles seem lax in piety, dress, service attendance,
fasting, and Orthodox zeal versus ethnic identity. These can be a
So, what's a Southern Orthodox Convert to do? Assimilation with the
Protestant milieu is not an option. Been there, was that.
Christianity plus icons and Typicon is not the answer. Why bother?
Becoming a dirt-eating-tree-hugging Druid is not the way. I mean,
really. Then again, these options are all alive and "well" within the
Church. And that may be okay, as far as God's concerned, but it comes
close to grits without salt for a Southerner.
Thanks to the War Between the States and Reconstruction, Southerners
have a strong distrust of outside authority. As the saying
goes, "Fool me once, shame on you; fool me twice, shame on me."
There's an underdog thread that binds us together. Yet when asked to
perform a task by those in authority, one can bet it shall be done.
We are teachable. However, all things must be in accord with proper
respect. Our experience teaches that there's virtue in losing when
done graciously. Nevertheless, we have strong suspicions regarding
authority. Those in positions of Orthodox leadership would do well to
familiarize themselves with the norms of Southern behaviour and
expectations. After all, if you are serious about evangelizing
another land, which the South definitely is, you would do no less!
This is not to say that the South should secede from the ethnic
Orthodoxy of the North. Rather, Southern Orthodoxy should be allowed
to flourish with its own personality and character with proper
hierarchical oversight. Any community that can appreciate this and
encourage Southerners toward the Kingdom within their own Southern
culture will do well in making solid Converts to the Faith in Dixie.
Father Joseph Huneycutt is pastor of St Raphael Orthodox Church in
Hendersonville, NC and is the author of the "blog"
visit him at http://southern-orthodoxy.blogspot.com/