Here is a link to online icons of numerous pre-Schism saints:http://www.odox.net/Icons-Western-Saints.htm
(I neither endorse nor slam the website; although I did live for some years where they are located, and knew of some interesting shenanigans.)
Down the page, you will find information links to a number of icon sources.
The group in Wisconsin (St. Isaac Skete) sells well-crafted icon print reproductions. Their icons are a good buy, if you find what you like.
In that "good icon" is subjective, to some extent, you can take or leave my remarks about another source listed there -- The Convent of St. Elizabeth. I once commissioned a copy of an icon that originally was painted by one of the nuns there. When the icon arrived, months later, I was horrified by its cartoon-like appearance. I would not order a handpainted icon from them, unless you can locate a satisfied customer to reassure you.
I hope you find what you want!