Well, putting my Vulcan-logic-analysis(TM) hat on, the response to "Some scholars" is first off, "What scholars? What are their names? What are their credentials? How many? Is it a major movement or a couple of cranks?" For such an assertion, there must be hard data given to back it up.
Many things that seem logical at first glance, Erracht, have gaps one could drive a tractor through side ways.