I've tried to replicate the error with Anti-Malware, but didn't find anything wrong with it.
I find it fairly odd, since the IP it is linking to seems to come up clean through Google clean browsing and through Anti-Malware itself. The best bet would be to check the logs to see what exactly it says is happening. A couple questions: a) when you load and refresh, in the status bar, do you notice it mentioning any site besides orthodoxchristianity.net?, b) are you having this problem with any other websites now or is it still just orthodoxchristinaity.net?
It sounds like it is likely more of a local problem, rather than something on the server. I'm not sure why that IP would even be mentioned in loading this site (and can't get it to do so on my own machine), unless something locally on your machine is trying to force it. It might also be a false positive.