For gifts, cookbooks and assorted other knicknacks I like light and life. Regarding books, one does need to be careful what they are buying from them. I have also spotted bunches of grammar errors, bad translations and red letter typos. If I'm going to buy a book about spirtuality, church history, prayer. I tend to use the reccomendations of others.
Here are my favorites
Narrow Path in Lansing Illinois - Very Serbcentric but good selection of Ikons and childrens books http://www.narrowpathbookstore.com/
You can buy items online.
Joy of All of Sorrow- Indianapolis Indiana. Nice over all selection of books. Good selection of Ikons, cadillos, insense, assorted gifts.
There is a new little bookstore and mission in Nashville Indiana called St. John the Barefoot. It's tiny with a good selection of ikons.