I may be reading you wrongly, but this makes no sense. First you have said that there are 30-50% of correct diagnoses, now you say the condition being diagnosed does not exist? Which is it?
It what I wrote…..:
50-70% of kids clamed “ADD” and “ADHD“ are undisciplined kids, for care givers and school not care for.
20-30% of ADD/ADHD kids are pure “cholerics” for it is type of them nerve system react on irritation.
I presume some “melancholics” couldbe on this list to, but I can’t tell for sure with out proper research.
May be I was to rush and not express myself clear but I mean next:
High percentage of those who was clamed as disorder (ADD or ADHD), not ill but simply kids who not get disciplined
. modern school not wecome disciplining kids, and modern society screw educational programmes.
If around child was created wrong and false environment
(wrong environment what is now promoted every where in world as healthy one) – as result, kids develop sort of animal behaviour with is easy fit in ADD and ADHD set criteria
Specially it would effects “holerics” and “melancholic” .
It is same as some on make “cant run disorder
I cant run for I have injured leg.
I cant run for I have head ache….
I cant run for I do not will obey your order
I cant run for I lazy
I cant run for my liver in pain
I cant run for I not see point of itBut for some one it would be “cant run disorder” for it suit to his project well.
I have see a lot of absolutely normal kids, who was diagnosed ADD for simple reason they are “choleric” by nature.
so, Other percentage who named ill - are “holerics” – which is way nerve system naturally work but is have no thing to do with disorder.
So what way them got treated ? drug abuse….
It same as we would make muscles transplant to turn sprinter into marathon. Same as some good for sprinting (white fibra) and other for marathon – (red fibre). Is it illness?