OrthodoxChristianity.net

General Forums => Christian News => Topic started by: Gunnarr on May 16, 2013, 01:34:08 PM

Title: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Gunnarr on May 16, 2013, 01:34:08 PM
Some articles:

http://www.globalpost.com/dispatch/news/afp/130516/georgian-orthodox-church-calls-gay-rally-ban (http://www.globalpost.com/dispatch/news/afp/130516/georgian-orthodox-church-calls-gay-rally-ban)

http://www.civil.ge/eng/article.php?id=26062 (http://www.civil.ge/eng/article.php?id=26062)

http://www.rferl.org/content/georgia-patriarch-gay-rights/24988151.html (http://www.rferl.org/content/georgia-patriarch-gay-rights/24988151.html)

He issued a statement about the issue, but I cannot find the original. But here are some excerpts from the statement taken from those articles, perhaps it is all of them. but I hope the statement by the patriarch is not copyright...:

“As it is known a rally of sexual minorities and their supporters is planned on the Rustaveli Avenue on May 17, which aims not at resolving real problems of these people, but at speculating by this issue, because it is the fact that despite of traditions and way of thinking that is established in our country, they [sexual minorities] can live their private life without restrictions,”

“It is also the fact that there are universal values, which are common across time and space – moral laws are among them. All the religions and scientific approaches (psychology and medicine) consider homosexuality to be anomaly and disease (of course we do not mean here newly created pseudo scientific views). The Church considers people with such inclinations to be in a grave sin, which need help and spiritual assistance as a remedy for correction, instead of encouragement and especially imposing their condition on population,”

“That would be similar to liking actions of a drug addict and making public display of drug addiction. Our people have different aspirations and for that reason it is understandable their sharp protest against this [planned May 17] and similar rallies.”

“Our citizens view [such rallies] as a violation of majority’s right and as an insult to their traditions, religion and in general to way of thinking,”

“We believe that the Tbilisi Mayor’s Office and the authorities should take into consideration these [factors] and revoke permission given to homosexuals for holding the rally, especially now when there is a nationwide mourning for fallen brave men [reference to three Georgian soldiers killed in Afghanistan]"
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Gunnarr on May 16, 2013, 02:48:31 PM
here is another article that just came up:

http://www.rawstory.com/rs/2013/05/16/georgias-orthodox-church-urges-ban-on-lgbt-rights-rally/

with lots of angry comments on the backwards conservative orthodox church hypocrits (just a paraphrase... not my words)
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Gunnarr on May 17, 2013, 04:07:01 PM
The rally still went, but there were many protests and it had to be ended and people evacuated by buses

http://rt.com/news/anti-gay-clashes-tbilisi-421/
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Alpo on May 17, 2013, 04:46:29 PM
The rally still went, but there were many protests and it had to be ended and people evacuated by buses

http://rt.com/news/anti-gay-clashes-tbilisi-421/

Disgusting. Believing in the Church's teaching is one thing and violent protests are wholly another thing.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: mike on May 17, 2013, 05:01:26 PM
The rally still went, but there were many protests and it had to be ended and people evacuated by buses

http://rt.com/news/anti-gay-clashes-tbilisi-421/

Disgusting. Believing in the Church's teaching is one thing and violent protests are wholly another thing.

+1
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: LizaSymonenko on May 17, 2013, 05:06:31 PM

They should have protested peacefully.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: mike on May 17, 2013, 05:08:58 PM

They should have protested peacefully.


Welcome to real world. This is how Orthodox protest against "sins".
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: podkarpatska on May 17, 2013, 05:13:02 PM
The rally still went, but there were many protests and it had to be ended and people evacuated by buses

http://rt.com/news/anti-gay-clashes-tbilisi-421/

Disgusting. Believing in the Church's teaching is one thing and violent protests are wholly another thing.

+1

+2. Kind of relates to the "tolerance" thread elsewhere and defining "tolerance." That surely wasn't it.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: LizaSymonenko on May 17, 2013, 05:13:26 PM
You are mistaken, once again.

This is NOT how all Orthodox protest against sin.

Why are you always so adamant to plop everyone in to one basket?

All Americans do this....

All Orthodox do that....

Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Gunnarr on May 17, 2013, 05:27:05 PM
The American Orthodox are much more enlightened than the backwards Georgian Orthodox
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: mike on May 17, 2013, 05:56:07 PM
You are mistaken, once again.

This is NOT how all Orthodox protest against sin.

Same in Serbia, Ukraine, Russia etc.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Tommelomsky on May 17, 2013, 06:09:00 PM
You are mistaken, once again.

This is NOT how all Orthodox protest against sin.

Why are you always so adamant to plop everyone in to one basket?

All Americans do this....

All Orthodox do that....



I wonder about the same thing.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Tommelomsky on May 17, 2013, 06:09:39 PM
The rally still went, but there were many protests and it had to be ended and people evacuated by buses

http://rt.com/news/anti-gay-clashes-tbilisi-421/

Disgusting. Believing in the Church's teaching is one thing and violent protests are wholly another thing.

+3.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: LizaSymonenko on May 17, 2013, 06:15:26 PM
You are mistaken, once again.

This is NOT how all Orthodox protest against sin.

Same in Serbia, Ukraine, Russia etc.

Really?  I hadn't heard about it.

Even so....they don't constitute ALL of Orthodoxy.

Do you act this way?  Because if ALL of Orthodoxy does, and you say you are Orthodox, than you must behave like this, as well.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Gunnarr on May 17, 2013, 06:19:56 PM
Do any of you believe that such protesters should be excommunicated unless they repent?

including the priests which also were in the protest

or if not, then is it not that bad then? how bad is it?
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: podkarpatska on May 17, 2013, 06:27:37 PM
You are mistaken, once again.

This is NOT how all Orthodox protest against sin.

Same in Serbia, Ukraine, Russia etc.

Really?  I hadn't heard about it.

Even so....they don't constitute ALL of Orthodoxy.

Do you act this way?  Because if ALL of Orthodoxy does, and you say you are Orthodox, than you must behave like this, as well.


I think the type of hooliganism exhibited is more common in the countries Michal referenced than we see, or would tolerate, in the US. I don't want to believe it is any more a reflection of Orthodoxy than say Westboro is a reflection of American Baptists.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: LizaSymonenko on May 17, 2013, 06:28:16 PM
Are we sure the clergymen were violent?  Perhaps they were merely marching in protest.

We do that here in the States during Pro-Life marches.  The priests and bishops are often seen marching in the crowds.

Out of the thousands present not all were throwing things.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Tommelomsky on May 17, 2013, 06:30:03 PM
Do any of you believe that such protesters should be excommunicated unless they repent?

including the priests which also were in the protest

or if not, then is it not that bad then? how bad is it?

Confession, repentance, almsgivings, prayer and spend some time to think about how you do things, why you do them and how you can improve spiritualitywise and as as witness of Christ.

addition: that is if they were involved violently.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: minasoliman on May 17, 2013, 06:40:03 PM
I would agree not "ALL" Orthodox act this way.  But I would say it's been common among places where Orthodoxy controls the government, or at least state-sponsored.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: podkarpatska on May 17, 2013, 06:44:41 PM
Are we sure the clergymen were violent?  Perhaps they were merely marching in protest.

We do that here in the States during Pro-Life marches.  The priests and bishops are often seen marching in the crowds.

Out of the thousands present not all were throwing things.

While I understand your unwillingness to believe that some priests and people could behave this way, it is not unprecedented. I remember an anti Jewish near riot in Georgia or Moldova two years ago as an example. Comparing what is clear  from the videos and pictures in Tbilisi to the American March for Life is really is an unintentional affront to the peaceful, prayeroful folks and clergy who attend the March each January in Washington.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: mike on May 17, 2013, 07:38:28 PM
Are we sure the clergymen were violent?  Perhaps they were merely marching in protest.

We do that here in the States during Pro-Life marches.  The priests and bishops are often seen marching in the crowds.

Out of the thousands present not all were throwing things.

Some priests or bishops bless such people or help them organise.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Gunnarr on May 17, 2013, 10:08:35 PM
Are we sure the clergymen were violent?  Perhaps they were merely marching in protest.

We do that here in the States during Pro-Life marches.  The priests and bishops are often seen marching in the crowds.

Out of the thousands present not all were throwing things.

I could not find any violent priests, I only saw them marching. But they clearly were also marching along with everyone else to break the police lines
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Shanghaiski on May 17, 2013, 10:17:32 PM
I would agree not "ALL" Orthodox act this way.  But I would say it's been common among places where Orthodoxy controls the government, or at least state-sponsored.

There's always going to be hooliganism. People who have not taken the Gospel to heart will not act according to the Gospel. They are usually a very small minority and are not blessed by the hierarchy. Take the Bosnian Civil War. Patriarch Pavle of blessed memory excommunicated those responsible for war crimes and atrocities. Still, people used the cover of the Church for committing crimes. That is a blot for them, not the Church.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Shanghaiski on May 17, 2013, 10:19:14 PM
It appears, in this case, the Georgian government and Church are at odds, unlike with the same case in Russia.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: GabrieltheCelt on May 17, 2013, 10:31:19 PM

They should have protested peacefully.


Welcome to real world. This is how Orthodox protest against "sins".

You're Orthodox, right?  Why do you protest against sins like that?  Or do you admit to over-generalizing?
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: GabrieltheCelt on May 17, 2013, 10:33:29 PM
The rally still went, but there were many protests and it had to be ended and people evacuated by buses

http://rt.com/news/anti-gay-clashes-tbilisi-421/

Disgusting. Believing in the Church's teaching is one thing and violent protests are wholly another thing.

+1

+2. Kind of relates to the "tolerance" thread elsewhere and defining "tolerance." That surely wasn't it.

A display of the opposite end of the spectrum.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Strongylocentrotus on May 17, 2013, 11:52:51 PM
I think that clerical violence has a long history in the Orthodox Church, just as in other churches.  Some may even call it an honorable tradition given the pious mythology that surrounds some of the church councils, like St. Nicolas punching Arius in nose during the first one. The emperor had to send in his "marines" to restore order.  Alexandria in particular was noted for the violent nature of her clerics and particularly her monks.  Remember the pagan philosopher Hypatia was shredded there by demented monastics.  The Patriarch Theophilus incited the burning of the library of Alexandria in 391.  Dear old St. Athanasius was a serial inciter of violence during his many intervals of restoration and exile  In the twentieth century orthodox clerics were instrumental in inciting progroms against Jews in Holy Russia and in  Romania,  Orthodox clerics were also active in the Black Hundreds and the Iron Guard.  Even today in Russia there are many clerics active in nationalist organizations that espouse violent rhetoric against various perceived enemies of Russia.  Finally, just a few years ago monks on the Holy Mountain were attacking each other with crowbars and sledgehammers, so yes, there is nothing unduly odd about monks and clerics running amok in Tbilisi.  What little I've managed to unearth about contemporary Georgia, it seems to be that certain nationalistic elements in Orthodox Georgia feel anxeity about both the "westernization" of Georgia and about their government's increasing tolerance of muslim and other refugees into Georgia, particularly Iranian expats.  Either way, in my humble opinion, the attitude of their patriarch says in all.  As has been observed, a fish rots from the head.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Punch on May 17, 2013, 11:58:03 PM
Gee, given the above reply, it would seem that the Georgian protesters were more Orthodox than the bleeding hearts on this forum, or at least more in tune with the Tradition of the Church.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Strongylocentrotus on May 18, 2013, 12:09:59 AM
Bless our "bleeding hearts", they are calling us to honor the better angels of our nature.  The Georgian reaction is atavistic and not sustainable in the long run.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: LizaSymonenko on May 18, 2013, 12:52:09 AM
Not sustainable in what sense?

That perhaps immoral behavior will be widely accepted there, like it is elsewhere?

I may not condone the violent methods, but I can understand the people's desire to preserve their nation and uphold moral, and dare I say Orthodox, morals and ethics in their country.


Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: NicholasMyra on May 18, 2013, 12:59:23 AM
"The name of God is blasphemed among the Gentiles through you."

That perhaps immoral behavior will be widely accepted there
Yes, because that is the greatest moral issue they're facing; gay people being openly gay.

Not the fact that their church has so much sickness that there is a violent protest.

You don't have to be Christian to protest against gays. Any pagan family worshiper can do that. Should we set up idols to Vesta?
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: LizaSymonenko on May 18, 2013, 01:05:57 AM

I never said it was their only issue.

From their recent history, I would wager they have a number of issues they are dealing with.

Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Maria on May 18, 2013, 01:08:15 AM
Not sustainable in what sense?

That perhaps immoral behavior will be widely accepted there, like it is elsewhere?

I may not condone the violent methods, but I can understand the people's desire to preserve their nation and uphold moral, and dare I say Orthodox, morals and ethics in their country.




Amen.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: NicholasMyra on May 18, 2013, 01:09:50 AM
From their recent history, I would wager they have a number of issues they are dealing with.
Wouldn't working mercy convert more than such protests?

Some day, whoever happens to be lording over that patch of dead earth will have to offer the nation's works to Christ.

You really want anti-gay protests to be part of that work?

There must be a better way.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Strongylocentrotus on May 18, 2013, 01:58:07 AM

I never said it was their only issue.

From their recent history, I would wager they have a number of issues they are dealing with.



No kidding?  This ain't about morality, that is just the excuse used to turn out the thugs.  Beating up on gays is just some opposition faction in Georgia flexing their political chops against the government currently in power.  The only question is whether it was with the active connivance of Church or not.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Romaios on May 18, 2013, 02:32:26 AM
Patriarch Ilia is very close to his people and he is very much revered. IIRC the Georgian Church was the first to pull out of the World Council of Churches and cut back on ecumenism - a very popular decision with the faithful. If the current government doesn't play this whole thing carefully, many Georgians might soon want to return to the arms of Mother Russia and leave the "corrupt West" to its fate.

Their president, however, would stupidly brag with his American allies and spit in the face of Russia. Ours was just as brave & wise.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Alpo on May 18, 2013, 02:41:28 AM
^Uhm...Corrupt West? Like Holy Mother Russia wasn't a lot more corrupted than any Western country.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Romaios on May 18, 2013, 02:42:37 AM
^Uhm...Corrupt West? Like Holy Mother Russia wasn't a lot more corrupted than any Western country.

Well, let me put it this way: Mr. Putin attends more Orthodox services than Mr. Obama does.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Alpo on May 18, 2013, 04:10:59 AM
^Uhm...Corrupt West? Like Holy Mother Russia wasn't a lot more corrupted than any Western country.

Well, let me put it this way: Mr. Putin attends more Orthodox services than Mr. Obama does.

While I'm not exactly a friend of American politics either but I value various freedoms and democracy more than state acting as a religious police.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Romaios on May 18, 2013, 04:24:16 AM
^Uhm...Corrupt West? Like Holy Mother Russia wasn't a lot more corrupted than any Western country.

Well, let me put it this way: Mr. Putin attends more Orthodox services than Mr. Obama does.

While I'm not exactly a friend of American politics either but I value various freedoms and democracy more than state acting as a religious police.

What if the Georgians democratically decide that they don't want gay parades in Georgia? 

What bothers me is that the people are never consulted on such issues. Before they are elected, (Eastern-European) politicians pose as pious and have discourses that reflect popular consensus on different issues - once voted, however, they seem to completely alter their agendas and ignore the will of those whom they are supposed to represent.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Kerdy on May 18, 2013, 04:27:34 AM

They should have protested peacefully.


Welcome to real world. This is how Orthodox protest against "sins".

No, it isn't.  Your "real world" doesn't exist.  You sure have a low opinion of Orthodox Christians who don't cater to your sensibilities.  Funny how everyone attacks Christians for this, yet remain silent when others employ the very same tactics.  Violent protest is disgusting, but it isn’t the only thing…
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Alpo on May 18, 2013, 04:28:54 AM
^Uhm...Corrupt West? Like Holy Mother Russia wasn't a lot more corrupted than any Western country.

Well, let me put it this way: Mr. Putin attends more Orthodox services than Mr. Obama does.

While I'm not exactly a friend of American politics either but I value various freedoms and democracy more than state acting as a religious police.

What if the Georgians democratically decide that they don't want gay parades in Georgia?  

If I was a Georgian I'd vote against it but this sure does sound a lot better idea than an angry violent mob taking justice into their own hands.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Romaios on May 18, 2013, 04:37:13 AM
What if the Georgians democratically decide that they don't want gay parades in Georgia?  

If I was a Georgian I'd vote against it but this sure does sound a lot better idea than an angry violent mob taking justice into their own hands.

Perhaps their elected representatives leave them no choice but to express their will in this manner.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Alpo on May 18, 2013, 04:39:52 AM
What if the Georgians democratically decide that they don't want gay parades in Georgia?  

If I was a Georgian I'd vote against it but this sure does sound a lot better idea than an angry violent mob taking justice into their own hands.

Perhaps their elected representatives leave them no choice but to express their will in this manner.

No. Violence against minorities is never right even if we happen to disagree with said minorities.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Kerdy on May 18, 2013, 04:41:56 AM
I love how they are titled anti-gay rather than pro-Christian (Orthodox).  It looks to me as if the priests are trying to get out of the way.

While I absolutely do not condone violent protests and the injury of people for no reason, we must be sensible and understand at some point people are either going to give in, as many here have done, or resist.  The opposition knows this all too well and will push with all its might to either get us to stop the good fight or fight back.  If we give in, they demand more.  If we resist, they point fingers and say stupid things like calling us intolerant or homophobic or some other nonsensical term.  They know this will happen and in the off chance it doesn’t, they make up some sort of lie to make people think it did.  If the government there knew it was dangerous, they should not have let it take place. 

Now on to the protestors.  If they initiated violence, they are wrong. 
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Kerdy on May 18, 2013, 04:42:44 AM
What if the Georgians democratically decide that they don't want gay parades in Georgia?  

If I was a Georgian I'd vote against it but this sure does sound a lot better idea than an angry violent mob taking justice into their own hands.

Perhaps their elected representatives leave them no choice but to express their will in this manner.

No. Violence against minorities is never right even if we happen to disagree with said minorities.

It has nothing to do with being in a minority status.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Kerdy on May 18, 2013, 04:44:00 AM
^Uhm...Corrupt West? Like Holy Mother Russia wasn't a lot more corrupted than any Western country.

Well, let me put it this way: Mr. Putin attends more Orthodox services than Mr. Obama does.

While I'm not exactly a friend of American politics either but I value various freedoms and democracy more than state acting as a religious police.

What if the Georgians democratically decide that they don't want gay parades in Georgia? 

What bothers me is that the people are never consulted on such issues. Before they are elected, (Eastern-European) politicians pose as pious and have discourses that reflect popular consensus on different issues - once voted, however, they seem to completely alter their agendas and ignore the will of those whom they are supposed to represent.

Same thing in America.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Romaios on May 18, 2013, 04:44:20 AM
No. Violence against minorities is never right even if we happen to disagree with said minorities.

I agree. That is exactly why the Georgian authorities should have thought twice before authorizing the gay parade.  
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: mike on May 18, 2013, 06:28:38 AM
There's always going to be hooliganism. People who have not taken the Gospel to heart will not act according to the Gospel. They are usually a very small minority and are not blessed by the hierarchy.

Wouldn't say they are small. And they are blessed sometimes:
http://vaticaninsider.lastampa.it/en/world-news/detail/articolo/russia-rusia-putin-19522/
http://www.businessinsider.com/golden-dawn-and-the-greek-orthodox-church-2012-10

You're Orthodox, right?  Why do you protest against sins like that?  Or do you admit to over-generalizing?

I do not protest. And I am not overgeneralizing since all anti-gay protests by patriotic Orthodox youth end up like that.

I may not condone the violent methods, but I can understand the people's desire to preserve their nation and uphold moral, and dare I say Orthodox, morals and ethics in their country.

Is fighting with the police or throwing rocks at gay parades a part of "Orthodox morals and ethics"? I do not want to be a part of it.

Well, let me put it this way: Mr. Putin attends more Orthodox services than Mr. Obama does.

He doesn't bring any of his mistresses, though.

No, it isn't.  Your "real world" doesn't exist.  You sure have a low opinion of Orthodox Christians who don't cater to your sensibilities.  Funny how everyone attacks Christians for this, yet remain silent when others employ the very same tactics.  Violent protest is disgusting, but it isn’t the only thing…

High time you left your convert kindergarten. If you dream about society with traditional Orthodox values, that' how it looks like.

It has nothing to do with being in a minority status.

It is. They were not protesting against eg. sex-selective abortion that is very popular there.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Tommelomsky on May 18, 2013, 06:29:32 AM
I understand why they protested, but it is sad if violence was used to make it be an effective rally.
As it is an issue that should be protested against.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Kerdy on May 18, 2013, 06:38:00 AM
There's always going to be hooliganism. People who have not taken the Gospel to heart will not act according to the Gospel. They are usually a very small minority and are not blessed by the hierarchy.

Wouldn't say they are small. And they are blessed sometimes:
http://vaticaninsider.lastampa.it/en/world-news/detail/articolo/russia-rusia-putin-19522/
http://www.businessinsider.com/golden-dawn-and-the-greek-orthodox-church-2012-10

You're Orthodox, right?  Why do you protest against sins like that?  Or do you admit to over-generalizing?

I do not protest. And I am not overgeneralizing since all anti-gay protests by patriotic Orthodox youth end up like that.

I may not condone the violent methods, but I can understand the people's desire to preserve their nation and uphold moral, and dare I say Orthodox, morals and ethics in their country.

Is fighting with the police or throwing rocks at gay parades a part of "Orthodox morals and ethics"? I do not want to be a part of it.

Well, let me put it this way: Mr. Putin attends more Orthodox services than Mr. Obama does.

He doesn't bring any of his mistresses, though.

No, it isn't.  Your "real world" doesn't exist.  You sure have a low opinion of Orthodox Christians who don't cater to your sensibilities.  Funny how everyone attacks Christians for this, yet remain silent when others employ the very same tactics.  Violent protest is disgusting, but it isn’t the only thing…

High time you left your convert kindergarten. If you dream about society with traditional Orthodox values, that' how it looks like.

It has nothing to do with being in a minority status.

It is. They were not protesting against eg. sex-selective abortion that is very popular there.
Kindergarten?  As if you have any room to say such things. And apparently it isn't what you say or everyone would be in agreement.  Think a little harder no matter how difficult it may be.  If your "vast" experience in Orthodoxy is so spot on, why are your statements so often in conflict with those who have been Orthodox longer.   Be careful, your bias is showing.

The last portion of your post is irrelevant, as seems to be the norm for you as of late.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Kerdy on May 18, 2013, 06:46:59 AM
I understand why they protested, but it is sad if violence was used to make it be an effective rally.
As it is an issue that should be protested against.
Agreed.  Violence is always a last option if at all possible and Christians the world over should be opposing such nonsense and sins rather than embrace them and make excuses for their exceptance.  I long for the time when Christians will stand for Christ without fear, with boldness.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: podkarpatska on May 18, 2013, 09:03:12 AM
^Uhm...Corrupt West? Like Holy Mother Russia wasn't a lot more corrupted than any Western country.

Well, let me put it this way: Mr. Putin attends more Orthodox services than Mr. Obama does.

A TOTAL non-sequitur. Putin purportedly is Orthodox and he and his allies have cunningly used the Church as the glue to sustain their nationalist agenda. Obama is not Orthodox and his country is far more multi religious than Putin's in terms of their being one overwhelmingly dominant Faith.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: podkarpatska on May 18, 2013, 09:04:35 AM
^Uhm...Corrupt West? Like Holy Mother Russia wasn't a lot more corrupted than any Western country.

Well, let me put it this way: Mr. Putin attends more Orthodox services than Mr. Obama does.

While I'm not exactly a friend of American politics either but I value various freedoms and democracy more than state acting as a religious police.

What if the Georgians democratically decide that they don't want gay parades in Georgia? 

What bothers me is that the people are never consulted on such issues. Before they are elected, (Eastern-European) politicians pose as pious and have discourses that reflect popular consensus on different issues - once voted, however, they seem to completely alter their agendas and ignore the will of those whom they are supposed to represent.

Oh, like the American south "democratically" disenfranchised and segregated blacks.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: mike on May 18, 2013, 09:11:51 AM
Why so surprised?

:(Watched the news on RT today and witnessed the violent and unedifying blockading of a so-called 'Gay Pride' parade. The news strip running below the news pictures had 'Christians block Gay Pride march'. The newsreader spoke of protestors lead by Orthodox Christian priests. What I saw extremely violent attacks on vehicles presumably trying to get the Pride marchers away in a minibus with broken windows and a screaming mob trying to knock seven barrels of .... out of whatever they could lay their fists on.

I have seen 'Gay Pride' marches before and found the over the top behaviour and outfits difficult to stomach, but this protest would best described as deeply shameful and mob violence rather than a protest by Christians.

Church Militant didn't even begin to describe it.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: podkarpatska on May 18, 2013, 09:21:48 AM
You are mostly missing Michal's point. Metropolitan Hilarion of the MP wrote a blogpost several years ago about the fragility of Orthodoxy in pre-Revolutionary Russia and his fear about the possible course of the future of its post communist revival. I couldn't find the original link, it was a thread years ago, but I found this excerpt, relevant here:

"(Metropolitan Hilarion) warns against a type of reactionary Orthodoxy that I see all too much of in the news:

The second danger is that. of militant Orthodoxy, which would be a post-atheist counterpart of militant atheism. I mean an Orthodoxy that fights against Jews, against masons, against democracy, against Western culture, against enlightenment. This type of Orthodoxy is being preached even by some key members of the hierarchy, and it has many supporters within the Church."

http://livingtext.wordpress.com/category/orthodoxy/
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Kerdy on May 18, 2013, 09:24:07 AM
Why so surprised?

:(Watched the news on RT today and witnessed the violent and unedifying blockading of a so-called 'Gay Pride' parade. The news strip running below the news pictures had 'Christians block Gay Pride march'. The newsreader spoke of protestors lead by Orthodox Christian priests. What I saw extremely violent attacks on vehicles presumably trying to get the Pride marchers away in a minibus with broken windows and a screaming mob trying to knock seven barrels of .... out of whatever they could lay their fists on.

I have seen 'Gay Pride' marches before and found the over the top behaviour and outfits difficult to stomach, but this protest would best described as deeply shameful and mob violence rather than a protest by Christians.

Church Militant didn't even begin to describe it.

You mean, they act just like the Orthodox Christians in Egypt and Syria (and other places where they are killed indiscriminately) who do this sort of thing? ::)  Seriously, Michael, pay attention and stop making obtuse statements.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: minasoliman on May 18, 2013, 09:32:28 AM
You are mostly missing Michal's point. Metropolitan Hilarion of the MP wrote a blogpost several years ago about the fragility of Orthodoxy in pre-Revolutionary Russia and his fear about the possible course of the future of its post communist revival. I couldn't find the original link, it was a thread years ago, but I found this excerpt, relevant here:

"(Metropolitan Hilarion) warns against a type of reactionary Orthodoxy that I see all too much of in the news:

The second danger is that. of militant Orthodoxy, which would be a post-atheist counterpart of militant atheism. I mean an Orthodoxy that fights against Jews, against masons, against democracy, against Western culture, against enlightenment. This type of Orthodoxy is being preached even by some key members of the hierarchy, and it has many supporters within the Church."

http://livingtext.wordpress.com/category/orthodoxy/
Wise words...one thing that needs to be preached against and with more "militancy" is the anti-militancy of the gospel.  Such people who act like militant Christians should be the first to be denounced as non-Christians, before all other apostates, sinners, and other religions.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Romaios on May 18, 2013, 09:35:36 AM
^Uhm...Corrupt West? Like Holy Mother Russia wasn't a lot more corrupted than any Western country.

Well, let me put it this way: Mr. Putin attends more Orthodox services than Mr. Obama does.

A TOTAL non-sequitur. Putin purportedly is Orthodox and he and his allies have cunningly used the Church as the glue to sustain their nationalist agenda. Obama is not Orthodox and his country is far more multi religious than Putin's in terms of their being one overwhelmingly dominant Faith.

The fact is that many Orthodox in Eastern Europe/the former Soviet countries tend to be increasingly anti-American. That doesn't automatically make them pro-Russian, but they feel - for instance - that gay people have enough rights as it is in their countries. Foreign support of gay activism or attempts to "liberate" such allegedly oppressed minorities are perceived as an infringement of their own cultural and religious values and even their national autonomy. The indigenous political class is perceived as too weak to stand up for these and too docile to their Western political and economical allies (i.e. "masters").
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Shanghaiski on May 18, 2013, 10:00:55 AM
^Uhm...Corrupt West? Like Holy Mother Russia wasn't a lot more corrupted than any Western country.

Pagan ancient Greece and Rome would be horrified by much of what happens publicly in the West.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Shanghaiski on May 18, 2013, 10:02:40 AM
^Uhm...Corrupt West? Like Holy Mother Russia wasn't a lot more corrupted than any Western country.

Well, let me put it this way: Mr. Putin attends more Orthodox services than Mr. Obama does.

While I'm not exactly a friend of American politics either but I value various freedoms and democracy more than state acting as a religious police.

What if the Georgians democratically decide that they don't want gay parades in Georgia?  

If I was a Georgian I'd vote against it but this sure does sound a lot better idea than an angry violent mob taking justice into their own hands.

Okay, show me where the angry, violent mob is. Where is the Catholicos Patriarch urging people to beat up gays? For God's sake...
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Shanghaiski on May 18, 2013, 10:04:13 AM
What if the Georgians democratically decide that they don't want gay parades in Georgia?  

If I was a Georgian I'd vote against it but this sure does sound a lot better idea than an angry violent mob taking justice into their own hands.

Perhaps their elected representatives leave them no choice but to express their will in this manner.

No. Violence against minorities is never right even if we happen to disagree with said minorities.

Come forth and denounce those who bless violence. Come, show the proof. Or just ignore the vast majority who aren't violent, who just do not want immorality to be treated as normal, who do not want naked people dancing in the streets for all to see.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Shanghaiski on May 18, 2013, 10:06:05 AM
^Uhm...Corrupt West? Like Holy Mother Russia wasn't a lot more corrupted than any Western country.

Well, let me put it this way: Mr. Putin attends more Orthodox services than Mr. Obama does.

While I'm not exactly a friend of American politics either but I value various freedoms and democracy more than state acting as a religious police.

What if the Georgians democratically decide that they don't want gay parades in Georgia? 

What bothers me is that the people are never consulted on such issues. Before they are elected, (Eastern-European) politicians pose as pious and have discourses that reflect popular consensus on different issues - once voted, however, they seem to completely alter their agendas and ignore the will of those whom they are supposed to represent.

Oh, like the American south "democratically" disenfranchised and segregated blacks.

Ahem, the Jim Crow laws were a Yankee import. There was not segregation as such during slavery.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Shanghaiski on May 18, 2013, 10:08:16 AM
You are mostly missing Michal's point. Metropolitan Hilarion of the MP wrote a blogpost several years ago about the fragility of Orthodoxy in pre-Revolutionary Russia and his fear about the possible course of the future of its post communist revival. I couldn't find the original link, it was a thread years ago, but I found this excerpt, relevant here:

"(Metropolitan Hilarion) warns against a type of reactionary Orthodoxy that I see all too much of in the news:

The second danger is that. of militant Orthodoxy, which would be a post-atheist counterpart of militant atheism. I mean an Orthodoxy that fights against Jews, against masons, against democracy, against Western culture, against enlightenment. This type of Orthodoxy is being preached even by some key members of the hierarchy, and it has many supporters within the Church."

http://livingtext.wordpress.com/category/orthodoxy/

Enligtenment, lol. His Eminence needs to read more Western history.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: podkarpatska on May 18, 2013, 10:09:35 AM
^Uhm...Corrupt West? Like Holy Mother Russia wasn't a lot more corrupted than any Western country.

Well, let me put it this way: Mr. Putin attends more Orthodox services than Mr. Obama does.

A TOTAL non-sequitur. Putin purportedly is Orthodox and he and his allies have cunningly used the Church as the glue to sustain their nationalist agenda. Obama is not Orthodox and his country is far more multi religious than Putin's in terms of their being one overwhelmingly dominant Faith.

The fact is that many Orthodox in Eastern Europe/the former Soviet countries tend to be increasingly anti-American. That doesn't automatically make them pro-Russian, but they feel - for instance - that gay people have enough rights as it is in their countries. Foreign support of gay activism or attempts to "liberate" such allegedly oppressed minorities are perceived as an infringement of their own cultural and religious values and even their national autonomy. The indigenous political class is perceived as too weak to stand up for these and too docile to their Western political and economical allies (i.e. "masters").

I agree and understand. Americans (myself included), left and center, are often culturally arrogant and commonly view the rest of the world in stark black and white, rather than shades of gray, based on their own point of view. We can't escape from our being taught "American exceptionalism" any more than a Russian or Georgian is shaped by their own versions of nationalist myopia.

Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Shanghaiski on May 18, 2013, 10:10:03 AM
You are mostly missing Michal's point. Metropolitan Hilarion of the MP wrote a blogpost several years ago about the fragility of Orthodoxy in pre-Revolutionary Russia and his fear about the possible course of the future of its post communist revival. I couldn't find the original link, it was a thread years ago, but I found this excerpt, relevant here:

"(Metropolitan Hilarion) warns against a type of reactionary Orthodoxy that I see all too much of in the news:

The second danger is that. of militant Orthodoxy, which would be a post-atheist counterpart of militant atheism. I mean an Orthodoxy that fights against Jews, against masons, against democracy, against Western culture, against enlightenment. This type of Orthodoxy is being preached even by some key members of the hierarchy, and it has many supporters within the Church."

http://livingtext.wordpress.com/category/orthodoxy/
Wise words...one thing that needs to be preached against and with more "militancy" is the anti-militancy of the gospel.  Such people who act like militant Christians should be the first to be denounced as non-Christians, before all other apostates, sinners, and other religions.

I'm sorry, but to rend the Church with mutual accusations of each other is the work of Satan. It is a sure recipe for chaos and a loss of faith. One can see it on this very forum.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: podkarpatska on May 18, 2013, 10:10:42 AM
^Uhm...Corrupt West? Like Holy Mother Russia wasn't a lot more corrupted than any Western country.

Well, let me put it this way: Mr. Putin attends more Orthodox services than Mr. Obama does.

While I'm not exactly a friend of American politics either but I value various freedoms and democracy more than state acting as a religious police.

What if the Georgians democratically decide that they don't want gay parades in Georgia? 

What bothers me is that the people are never consulted on such issues. Before they are elected, (Eastern-European) politicians pose as pious and have discourses that reflect popular consensus on different issues - once voted, however, they seem to completely alter their agendas and ignore the will of those whom they are supposed to represent.

Oh, like the American south "democratically" disenfranchised and segregated blacks.

Ahem, the Jim Crow laws were a Yankee import. There was not segregation as such during slavery.

Revisionist.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: mike on May 18, 2013, 10:15:23 AM
You mean, they act just like the Orthodox Christians in Egypt and Syria (and other places where they are killed indiscriminately) who do this sort of thing? ::)  Seriously, Michael, pay attention and stop making obtuse statements.

I've never heard of Copts making pogroms.

Okay, show me where the angry, violent mob is.

Here: http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=_f4lMuAhORU
http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=7uC7VYF0NBI

(in the 2nd one there are gays being evacuated by the police. Orthodox activists say them 'goodbye')

Come forth and denounce those who bless violence. Come, show the proof.

I've already posted a link about Russian Church organising paramilitary militia.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: podkarpatska on May 18, 2013, 10:18:10 AM
I understand the militancy of faith, but I must have missed the part of Christ's teaching about taking sticks rocks and rioting. That must come after the stuff about seventy time seven is exhausted.  

But for the despised Enlightenment we all would be serfs anyway, if I existed I would still be a Greek Catholic cutting timber in the Tatras and North America would either still be under the British Crown or be a collection of separate nations,feuding some successful and some not like South America. Oh yeah, the Pope and the Papal States would have nukes.....
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Shanghaiski on May 18, 2013, 10:31:23 AM
^Uhm...Corrupt West? Like Holy Mother Russia wasn't a lot more corrupted than any Western country.

Well, let me put it this way: Mr. Putin attends more Orthodox services than Mr. Obama does.

While I'm not exactly a friend of American politics either but I value various freedoms and democracy more than state acting as a religious police.

What if the Georgians democratically decide that they don't want gay parades in Georgia? 

What bothers me is that the people are never consulted on such issues. Before they are elected, (Eastern-European) politicians pose as pious and have discourses that reflect popular consensus on different issues - once voted, however, they seem to completely alter their agendas and ignore the will of those whom they are supposed to represent.

Oh, like the American south "democratically" disenfranchised and segregated blacks.

Ahem, the Jim Crow laws were a Yankee import. There was not segregation as such during slavery.

Revisionist.

LOL. Revisionist history often corrects blatant errors. Or would you just accept Gibbon's take on the Eastern Romans?
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: podkarpatska on May 18, 2013, 10:45:08 AM
Non sequitur. Gibbons was wrong, therefore Jim Crow was sustained into the late 20th century by the descendants of the carpetbagging Yankees. Right....
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: augustin717 on May 18, 2013, 10:51:00 AM
I'm no big fan of identity politics. That said here the problems is that many Georgian citizens do not understand that that not all Georgian citizens will publicly  congregate  to carry icons and banned and crosses. Some will for wine festivals, other to protest the govt others for gay parades others for bovine expositions etc. assuming the Georgian laws guaranteed freedom to assemble peacefully. And I think it does. The Romanian hierarchy probably no less homophobic is still more cautious with language at least. Maybe the consequence of milking some EU funds. I think they no longer issue protests on every occasion 20 gays congregate. But then again rampant violent homophobia is itself most likely gay. You know probably people that are told personally or just get the general message that they would carry their cross and shut up. Happy content heterosexuals don't foam at the mouth at the sight of homosexuals.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: GabrieltheCelt on May 18, 2013, 10:59:08 AM
Non sequitur. Gibbons was wrong, therefore Jim Crow was sustained into the late 20th century by the descendants of the carpetbagging Yankees. Right....

 This message was brought to you by the New England Historical Society and was made possible by generous donations and posters like you.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Punch on May 18, 2013, 11:07:16 AM

High time you left your convert kindergarten. If you dream about society with traditional Orthodox values, that' how it looks like.



Wise words from our saintly Polish boy.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Romaios on May 18, 2013, 11:11:23 AM
I'm no big fan of identity politics. That said here the problems is that many Georgian citizens do not understand that that not all Georgian citizens will publicly  congregate  to carry icons and banned and crosses. Some will for wine festivals, other to protest the govt others for gay parades others for bovine expositions etc. assuming the Georgian laws guaranteed freedom to assemble peacefully. And I think it does.

So they need to be "educated" that a gay parade is no different from a bovine exposition.  ;D

But then again rampant violent homophobia is itself most likely gay. You know probably people that are told personally or just get the general message that they would carry their cross and shut up. Happy content heterosexuals don't foam at the mouth at the sight of homosexuals.

That's it - all those Georgians are crypto-homosexuals jealous of their liberated counterparts. ::)
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Punch on May 18, 2013, 11:12:48 AM
^Uhm...Corrupt West? Like Holy Mother Russia wasn't a lot more corrupted than any Western country.

Well, let me put it this way: Mr. Putin attends more Orthodox services than Mr. Obama does.

A TOTAL non-sequitur. Putin purportedly is Orthodox and he and his allies have cunningly used the Church as the glue to sustain their nationalist agenda. Obama is not Orthodox and his country is far more multi religious than Putin's in terms of their being one overwhelmingly dominant Faith.

Yes, the true ecumenist comes out.  "Multi-religious" as a virtue.  Thank God for Putin and his "purported" Orthodoxy.  At least he pretends, unlike many on this forum.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Shanghaiski on May 18, 2013, 11:14:51 AM
Non sequitur. Gibbons was wrong, therefore Jim Crow was sustained into the late 20th century by the descendants of the carpetbagging Yankees. Right....

You misunderstood me. When I said Yankee import, I meant that the laws were used first in the North, then imported in the South. Then, later, the laws were slowly changed in the North, but remained in the South.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: 88Devin12 on May 18, 2013, 11:41:05 AM
At least they have the guts to stand up against "gay rights" rallies. I spent 5 years at a liberal university where I had to put up with such propaganda. I personally have several good friends who have homosexual attractions to other men. However, just because I love them and they are my friends doesn't mean I will ever approve of their decisions. I'm obviously against gay marriage, but not necessarily against remodeling our civil "marriage" system to be civil unions. As has been said elsewhere, while we don't agree with homosexual relationships, the issue with "marriage" in the civil society, is that if they need access to their partner in the hospital, or their partner wishes them to have the rights of a family member, why should we stop them? Our disagreement is over their sexual relationship, not over civil rights.

It is right to stand against the promotion of sexual immorality. What isn't right is doing so with violence. I'm not a big fan of unbridled free speech, so I don't have a problem with Russia, Georgia or other nations suppressing such rallies. My problem is with the Orthodox who react with violence against the gay community.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: minasoliman on May 18, 2013, 11:42:12 AM
You are mostly missing Michal's point. Metropolitan Hilarion of the MP wrote a blogpost several years ago about the fragility of Orthodoxy in pre-Revolutionary Russia and his fear about the possible course of the future of its post communist revival. I couldn't find the original link, it was a thread years ago, but I found this excerpt, relevant here:

"(Metropolitan Hilarion) warns against a type of reactionary Orthodoxy that I see all too much of in the news:

The second danger is that. of militant Orthodoxy, which would be a post-atheist counterpart of militant atheism. I mean an Orthodoxy that fights against Jews, against masons, against democracy, against Western culture, against enlightenment. This type of Orthodoxy is being preached even by some key members of the hierarchy, and it has many supporters within the Church."

http://livingtext.wordpress.com/category/orthodoxy/
Wise words...one thing that needs to be preached against and with more "militancy" is the anti-militancy of the gospel.  Such people who act like militant Christians should be the first to be denounced as non-Christians, before all other apostates, sinners, and other religions.

I'm sorry, but to rend the Church with mutual accusations of each other is the work of Satan. It is a sure recipe for chaos and a loss of faith. One can see it on this very forum.

As opposed to silence and looking as if Orthodoxy endorses such behavior?  Might as well allow the Muslims to sing in honor of the terrorist Christians to expose our alleged hypocrisy.   The Egyptian Muslim author did so with his novel "Azazel" to show that St. Cyril was a terrorist leader that lead the killing of Hypatia, despite research not able to prove it.  Nevertheless, it makes a juicy opportunity for the non-Christians.  So why shouldn't we be strong in our condemnations of these so-called "Orthodox Christians"?
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: augustin717 on May 18, 2013, 11:44:02 AM
At least they have the guts to stand up against "gay rights" rallies. I spent 5 years at a liberal university where I had to put up with such propaganda. I personally have several good friends who have homosexual attractions to other men. However, just because I love them and they are my friends doesn't mean I will ever approve of their decisions. I'm obviously against gay marriage, but not necessarily against remodeling our civil "marriage" system to be civil unions. As has been said elsewhere, while we don't agree with homosexual relationships, the issue with "marriage" in the civil society, is that if they need access to their partner in the hospital, or their partner wishes them to have the rights of a family member, why should we stop them? Our disagreement is over their sexual relationship, not over civil rights.

It is right to stand against the promotion of sexual immorality. What isn't right is doing so with violence. I'm not a big fan of unbridled free speech, so I don't have a problem with Russia, Georgia or other nations suppressing such rallies. My problem is with the Orthodox who react with violence against the gay community.
you'd, one thinks, know that to be part of  mob no extraordinary amount of guts is required. more guts were required for the few gay people to walk around surrounded by that mob.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: 88Devin12 on May 18, 2013, 11:46:50 AM
you'd, one thinks, know that to be part of  mob no extraordinary amount of guts is required. more guts were required for the few gay people to walk around surrounded by that mob.

I'm referring to Patriarch Ilia and other figures like the mayor of Moscow who have come out against gay rallies. They have more guts than the chickens over in Western Europe.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: minasoliman on May 18, 2013, 11:50:42 AM
you'd, one thinks, know that to be part of  mob no extraordinary amount of guts is required. more guts were required for the few gay people to walk around surrounded by that mob.

I'm referring to Patriarch Ilia and other figures like the mayor of Moscow who have come out against gay rallies. They have more guts than the chickens over in Western Europe.

In Georgia?  Is Georgia really that liberal for the patriarch to show "bravery" in taking a stand?  Isn't Orthodox Christianity the state sponsored religion?

Devin, yes, here in the US and other liberal countries, it takes guts standing against homosexuality.  But in Georgia where being Orthodox Christian is the norm, even the patriarch does not require guts.  Guts would be standing against the status quo in a society.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: 88Devin12 on May 18, 2013, 11:51:57 AM
I'll play ialmisry for a second here:

(http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/d/dd/Same_sex_marriage_map_Europe_detailed.svg)

Nations and their limitations on gay marriage in Europe, dark blue allows same-sex marriages, blue allows other types of partnerships, light blue allows cohabitation, grey doesn't recognize same-sex marriages, red limits marriage to heterosexual couples.

(http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/4/47/Europe_belief_in_god.svg/524px-Europe_belief_in_god.svg.png)

This shows European nations and belief in God. Lighter indicates higher rates of atheism, darker indicates higher belief in God.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: 88Devin12 on May 18, 2013, 11:52:42 AM
you'd, one thinks, know that to be part of  mob no extraordinary amount of guts is required. more guts were required for the few gay people to walk around surrounded by that mob.

I'm referring to Patriarch Ilia and other figures like the mayor of Moscow who have come out against gay rallies. They have more guts than the chickens over in Western Europe.

In Georgia?  Is Georgia really that liberal for the patriarch to show "bravery" in taking a stand?  Isn't Orthodox Christianity the state sponsored religion?

Devin, yes, here in the US and other liberal countries, it takes guts standing against homosexuality.  But in Georgia where being Orthodox Christian is the norm, even the patriarch does not require guts.  Guts would be standing against the status quo in a society.

Guts on the world stage, where they are accused to being oppressive and violating human rights, not guts in their own country.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: augustin717 on May 18, 2013, 11:53:26 AM
you'd, one thinks, know that to be part of  mob no extraordinary amount of guts is required. more guts were required for the few gay people to walk around surrounded by that mob.

I'm referring to Patriarch Ilia and other figures like the mayor of Moscow who have come out against gay rallies. They have more guts than the chickens over in Western Europe.
the mayor of Moscow is, I assume, a puppet of Putin's . So he wouldn't do a thing against    his wishes. so, no guts there. I don't know in what terms patriarch Ilia is to the Georgian political establishment. it might be  the Church flexing their muscles at a gay parade. Possible.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: minasoliman on May 18, 2013, 11:56:05 AM
you'd, one thinks, know that to be part of  mob no extraordinary amount of guts is required. more guts were required for the few gay people to walk around surrounded by that mob.

I'm referring to Patriarch Ilia and other figures like the mayor of Moscow who have come out against gay rallies. They have more guts than the chickens over in Western Europe.

In Georgia?  Is Georgia really that liberal for the patriarch to show "bravery" in taking a stand?  Isn't Orthodox Christianity the state sponsored religion?

Devin, yes, here in the US and other liberal countries, it takes guts standing against homosexuality.  But in Georgia where being Orthodox Christian is the norm, even the patriarch does not require guts.  Guts would be standing against the status quo in a society.

Guts on the world stage, where they are accused to being oppressive and violating human rights, not guts in their own country.

They have the safe haven of their own country.  The world may say whatever they want.  If that's the case, Saudi Arabia has big cahonays (sp?) for continuing to make it illegal for women to drive.  That's not guts.  It's guts if all of a sudden the country is controlled by the world.  The Muslim Brotherhood has guts for attacking the Coptic cathedral.  Ya...sounds like guts.  The world decries, and the country doesn't change.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: 88Devin12 on May 18, 2013, 11:58:37 AM
you'd, one thinks, know that to be part of  mob no extraordinary amount of guts is required. more guts were required for the few gay people to walk around surrounded by that mob.

I'm referring to Patriarch Ilia and other figures like the mayor of Moscow who have come out against gay rallies. They have more guts than the chickens over in Western Europe.
the mayor of Moscow is, I assume, a puppet of Putin's . So he wouldn't do a thing against    his wishes. so, no guts there. I don't know in what terms patriarch Ilia is to the Georgian political establishment. it might be  the Church flexing its muscles at a gay parade. Possible.

Nothing wrong with Putin... He may not be the most "diplomatic" leader, but he is the strongest leader the world has seen in years, and at least he stands for what is right, even if he doesn't always do things in a "democratic" manner.

The last strong leader Russia had was Stalin, and Putin is a heck of a lot better than him. The only "contemporary" leader we have had that could compare would have been Roosevelt. It's too bad we can't have strong leaders anymore, the longest anyone can actually hold power is 8 years and that isn't enough time to really establish a strong rule and lasting changes.

(also, just fyi, I don't mean strong as in good or moral)
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: minasoliman on May 18, 2013, 12:01:47 PM
(also, just fyi, I don't mean strong as in good or moral)

Still..."strength" is quite a stretch, especially when you want to consider the spiritual understanding of true strength.

Is it really "strength" for a mob President to use the mob to hush his opponents?
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: augustin717 on May 18, 2013, 12:02:13 PM
And this:http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-22509019 (http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-22509019)
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: 88Devin12 on May 18, 2013, 12:03:34 PM
(also, just fyi, I don't mean strong as in good or moral)

Still..."strength" is quite a stretch, especially when you want to consider the spiritual understanding of true strength.

Is it really "strength" for a mob President to use the mob to hush his opponents?

Leaders like Hitler, Stalin and others could all be considered strong leaders, despite the terrible things they did.

A good leader is different than a strong leader.

In my opinion, Putin is a strong leader, but in many ways is also a good leader, because he has helped get Russia off its backside and towards recovery. Despite the wide variety of problems in post-Soviet Russia, the nation definitely has already recovered well.

And just FYI, silencing political opponents isn't necessarily a big deal. Keep in mind that you are talking to a monarchist. If Putin uses his power to silence the communists in Russia, then all power to him. If he also wants to silence those who want Russia to become like Western Europe, then I'm all for silencing them. (I don't mean by killing)
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Shanghaiski on May 18, 2013, 12:04:21 PM
You are mostly missing Michal's point. Metropolitan Hilarion of the MP wrote a blogpost several years ago about the fragility of Orthodoxy in pre-Revolutionary Russia and his fear about the possible course of the future of its post communist revival. I couldn't find the original link, it was a thread years ago, but I found this excerpt, relevant here:

"(Metropolitan Hilarion) warns against a type of reactionary Orthodoxy that I see all too much of in the news:

The second danger is that. of militant Orthodoxy, which would be a post-atheist counterpart of militant atheism. I mean an Orthodoxy that fights against Jews, against masons, against democracy, against Western culture, against enlightenment. This type of Orthodoxy is being preached even by some key members of the hierarchy, and it has many supporters within the Church."

http://livingtext.wordpress.com/category/orthodoxy/
Wise words...one thing that needs to be preached against and with more "militancy" is the anti-militancy of the gospel.  Such people who act like militant Christians should be the first to be denounced as non-Christians, before all other apostates, sinners, and other religions.

I'm sorry, but to rend the Church with mutual accusations of each other is the work of Satan. It is a sure recipe for chaos and a loss of faith. One can see it on this very forum.

As opposed to silence and looking as if Orthodoxy endorses such behavior?  Might as well allow the Muslims to sing in honor of the terrorist Christians to expose our alleged hypocrisy.   The Egyptian Muslim author did so with his novel "Azazel" to show that St. Cyril was a terrorist leader that lead the killing of Hypatia, despite research not able to prove it.  Nevertheless, it makes a juicy opportunity for the non-Christians.  So why shouldn't we be strong in our condemnations of these so-called "Orthodox Christians"?

I condemn the violence as well as the support for sexual immorality. The ideology of the latter, however, is provocative. As far as I know, most of the demonstrators against it were not violent, nor did His Holiness and Beatitude advocate violence.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: minasoliman on May 18, 2013, 12:05:19 PM
(also, just fyi, I don't mean strong as in good or moral)

Still..."strength" is quite a stretch, especially when you want to consider the spiritual understanding of true strength.

Is it really "strength" for a mob President to use the mob to hush his opponents?

Leaders like Hitler, Stalin and others could all be considered strong leaders, despite the terrible things they did.

A good leader is different than a strong leader.

Hitler and Stalin are weak leaders to me.  In their insecurities, they killed the masses so that they give an illusion of strength.

My spiritual father taught me a lesson.  Which is stronger?  To hate your enemies, or to love them?  Then you'll know, "leaders" like Hitler and Stalin were the weakest.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: minasoliman on May 18, 2013, 12:06:42 PM
You are mostly missing Michal's point. Metropolitan Hilarion of the MP wrote a blogpost several years ago about the fragility of Orthodoxy in pre-Revolutionary Russia and his fear about the possible course of the future of its post communist revival. I couldn't find the original link, it was a thread years ago, but I found this excerpt, relevant here:

"(Metropolitan Hilarion) warns against a type of reactionary Orthodoxy that I see all too much of in the news:

The second danger is that. of militant Orthodoxy, which would be a post-atheist counterpart of militant atheism. I mean an Orthodoxy that fights against Jews, against masons, against democracy, against Western culture, against enlightenment. This type of Orthodoxy is being preached even by some key members of the hierarchy, and it has many supporters within the Church."

http://livingtext.wordpress.com/category/orthodoxy/
Wise words...one thing that needs to be preached against and with more "militancy" is the anti-militancy of the gospel.  Such people who act like militant Christians should be the first to be denounced as non-Christians, before all other apostates, sinners, and other religions.

I'm sorry, but to rend the Church with mutual accusations of each other is the work of Satan. It is a sure recipe for chaos and a loss of faith. One can see it on this very forum.

As opposed to silence and looking as if Orthodoxy endorses such behavior?  Might as well allow the Muslims to sing in honor of the terrorist Christians to expose our alleged hypocrisy.   The Egyptian Muslim author did so with his novel "Azazel" to show that St. Cyril was a terrorist leader that lead the killing of Hypatia, despite research not able to prove it.  Nevertheless, it makes a juicy opportunity for the non-Christians.  So why shouldn't we be strong in our condemnations of these so-called "Orthodox Christians"?

I condemn the violence as well as the support for sexual immorality. The ideology of the latter, however, is provocative. As far as I know, most of the demonstrators against it were not violent, nor did His Holiness and Beatitude advocate violence.

Then I'd like to see them come out and condemn the violence that happened.  I'd like to see some of those priests provide for the well-being of those injured and killed.  A father may have not told his son to go and throw stones, but when a son goes and throws stones, the father is still responsible.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Shanghaiski on May 18, 2013, 12:06:53 PM
you'd, one thinks, know that to be part of  mob no extraordinary amount of guts is required. more guts were required for the few gay people to walk around surrounded by that mob.

I'm referring to Patriarch Ilia and other figures like the mayor of Moscow who have come out against gay rallies. They have more guts than the chickens over in Western Europe.

In Georgia?  Is Georgia really that liberal for the patriarch to show "bravery" in taking a stand?  Isn't Orthodox Christianity the state sponsored religion?

Devin, yes, here in the US and other liberal countries, it takes guts standing against homosexuality.  But in Georgia where being Orthodox Christian is the norm, even the patriarch does not require guts.  Guts would be standing against the status quo in a society.

Apparently in Georgia, the Church is not supported by the state--at the insistence of the Catholicos Patriarch. The patriarch is standing against the leaders of the state, who are pandering to Europe.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: minasoliman on May 18, 2013, 12:09:27 PM
you'd, one thinks, know that to be part of  mob no extraordinary amount of guts is required. more guts were required for the few gay people to walk around surrounded by that mob.

I'm referring to Patriarch Ilia and other figures like the mayor of Moscow who have come out against gay rallies. They have more guts than the chickens over in Western Europe.

In Georgia?  Is Georgia really that liberal for the patriarch to show "bravery" in taking a stand?  Isn't Orthodox Christianity the state sponsored religion?

Devin, yes, here in the US and other liberal countries, it takes guts standing against homosexuality.  But in Georgia where being Orthodox Christian is the norm, even the patriarch does not require guts.  Guts would be standing against the status quo in a society.

Apparently in Georgia, the Church is not supported by the state--at the insistence of the Catholicos Patriarch. The patriarch is standing against the leaders of the state, who are pandering to Europe.
Does that lessen my argument somehow?  Is the Church a minority?  Is the Church a weak body in the country?
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Shanghaiski on May 18, 2013, 12:09:41 PM
you'd, one thinks, know that to be part of  mob no extraordinary amount of guts is required. more guts were required for the few gay people to walk around surrounded by that mob.

I'm referring to Patriarch Ilia and other figures like the mayor of Moscow who have come out against gay rallies. They have more guts than the chickens over in Western Europe.

In Georgia?  Is Georgia really that liberal for the patriarch to show "bravery" in taking a stand?  Isn't Orthodox Christianity the state sponsored religion?

Devin, yes, here in the US and other liberal countries, it takes guts standing against homosexuality.  But in Georgia where being Orthodox Christian is the norm, even the patriarch does not require guts.  Guts would be standing against the status quo in a society.

Guts on the world stage, where they are accused to being oppressive and violating human rights, not guts in their own country.

They have the safe haven of their own country.  The world may say whatever they want.  If that's the case, Saudi Arabia has big cahonays (sp?) for continuing to make it illegal for women to drive.  That's not guts.  It's guts if all of a sudden the country is controlled by the world.  The Muslim Brotherhood has guts for attacking the Coptic cathedral.  Ya...sounds like guts.  The world decries, and the country doesn't change.

Why use Mohammedans as a point of reference for anything?
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: 88Devin12 on May 18, 2013, 12:10:00 PM
you'd, one thinks, know that to be part of  mob no extraordinary amount of guts is required. more guts were required for the few gay people to walk around surrounded by that mob.

I'm referring to Patriarch Ilia and other figures like the mayor of Moscow who have come out against gay rallies. They have more guts than the chickens over in Western Europe.

In Georgia?  Is Georgia really that liberal for the patriarch to show "bravery" in taking a stand?  Isn't Orthodox Christianity the state sponsored religion?

Devin, yes, here in the US and other liberal countries, it takes guts standing against homosexuality.  But in Georgia where being Orthodox Christian is the norm, even the patriarch does not require guts.  Guts would be standing against the status quo in a society.

Apparently in Georgia, the Church is not supported by the state--at the insistence of the Catholicos Patriarch. The patriarch is standing against the leaders of the state, who are pandering to Europe.

Georgia has proven to be almost a puppet of Western Europe and the United States, so implications that his holiness Patriarch Ilia is a puppet of Georgia is laughable.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: minasoliman on May 18, 2013, 12:11:08 PM
you'd, one thinks, know that to be part of  mob no extraordinary amount of guts is required. more guts were required for the few gay people to walk around surrounded by that mob.

I'm referring to Patriarch Ilia and other figures like the mayor of Moscow who have come out against gay rallies. They have more guts than the chickens over in Western Europe.

In Georgia?  Is Georgia really that liberal for the patriarch to show "bravery" in taking a stand?  Isn't Orthodox Christianity the state sponsored religion?

Devin, yes, here in the US and other liberal countries, it takes guts standing against homosexuality.  But in Georgia where being Orthodox Christian is the norm, even the patriarch does not require guts.  Guts would be standing against the status quo in a society.

Guts on the world stage, where they are accused to being oppressive and violating human rights, not guts in their own country.

They have the safe haven of their own country.  The world may say whatever they want.  If that's the case, Saudi Arabia has big cahonays (sp?) for continuing to make it illegal for women to drive.  That's not guts.  It's guts if all of a sudden the country is controlled by the world.  The Muslim Brotherhood has guts for attacking the Coptic cathedral.  Ya...sounds like guts.  The world decries, and the country doesn't change.

Why use Mohammedans as a point of reference for anything?
Because when someone says that someone in a remote country has guts against the world opinion, then by consistency, even they have guts.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: 88Devin12 on May 18, 2013, 12:13:52 PM
(also, just fyi, I don't mean strong as in good or moral)

Still..."strength" is quite a stretch, especially when you want to consider the spiritual understanding of true strength.

Is it really "strength" for a mob President to use the mob to hush his opponents?

Leaders like Hitler, Stalin and others could all be considered strong leaders, despite the terrible things they did.

A good leader is different than a strong leader.

Hitler and Stalin are weak leaders to me.  In their insecurities, they killed the masses so that they give an illusion of strength.

My spiritual father taught me a lesson.  Which is stronger?  To hate your enemies, or to love them?  Then you'll know, "leaders" like Hitler and Stalin were the weakest.

I'm not talking about strong in terms of faith. If you want to talk about leaders strong in faith, we can talk about St. Justinian, St. Sava and his father St. Stefan, St. Vladimir the Great and others.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Shanghaiski on May 18, 2013, 12:18:51 PM
you'd, one thinks, know that to be part of  mob no extraordinary amount of guts is required. more guts were required for the few gay people to walk around surrounded by that mob.

I'm referring to Patriarch Ilia and other figures like the mayor of Moscow who have come out against gay rallies. They have more guts than the chickens over in Western Europe.

In Georgia?  Is Georgia really that liberal for the patriarch to show "bravery" in taking a stand?  Isn't Orthodox Christianity the state sponsored religion?

Devin, yes, here in the US and other liberal countries, it takes guts standing against homosexuality.  But in Georgia where being Orthodox Christian is the norm, even the patriarch does not require guts.  Guts would be standing against the status quo in a society.

Apparently in Georgia, the Church is not supported by the state--at the insistence of the Catholicos Patriarch. The patriarch is standing against the leaders of the state, who are pandering to Europe.
Does that lessen my argument somehow?  Is the Church a minority?  Is the Church a weak body in the country?

And should the Church of Georgia sanction gay pride parades? Shall it allow the state to destroy its traditional culture (that is, communism all over again)?

People were hurt. That was unfortunate, and possibly wrong (do we know the actual circumstances? What is the evidence? Do we condemn based off news reports and hearsay?).

This isn't to comment on this case, but when Christians are confronted by blasphemy, even the response of the holy is not bashful.

Arius uttered blasphemy. St. Nicholas smacked him. Men punished St. Nicholas and protected Arius. But God Himself restored St. Nicholas to his office as one not worthy of condemnation because Arius was deserving of rebuke.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: minasoliman on May 18, 2013, 12:19:04 PM
(also, just fyi, I don't mean strong as in good or moral)

Still..."strength" is quite a stretch, especially when you want to consider the spiritual understanding of true strength.

Is it really "strength" for a mob President to use the mob to hush his opponents?

Leaders like Hitler, Stalin and others could all be considered strong leaders, despite the terrible things they did.

A good leader is different than a strong leader.

Hitler and Stalin are weak leaders to me.  In their insecurities, they killed the masses so that they give an illusion of strength.

My spiritual father taught me a lesson.  Which is stronger?  To hate your enemies, or to love them?  Then you'll know, "leaders" like Hitler and Stalin were the weakest.

I'm not talking about strong in terms of faith. If you want to talk about leaders strong in faith, we can talk about St. Justinian, St. Sava and his father St. Stefan, St. Vladimir the Great and others.

Memories of these men live on as inspirations, while the memories of Stalin and Hitler will live on as damnworthy.  If only making long-lasting memories gives someone strength, then the saints as much as the tyrants are equally strong.  I make no distinction, even on a moral level, let alone spiritual.  Tyrants withered away time and again, which only proves their inherent weaknesses, not strengths.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: augustin717 on May 18, 2013, 12:22:34 PM
you'd, one thinks, know that to be part of  mob no extraordinary amount of guts is required. more guts were required for the few gay people to walk around surrounded by that mob.

I'm referring to Patriarch Ilia and other figures like the mayor of Moscow who have come out against gay rallies. They have more guts than the chickens over in Western Europe.

In Georgia?  Is Georgia really that liberal for the patriarch to show "bravery" in taking a stand?  Isn't Orthodox Christianity the state sponsored religion?

Devin, yes, here in the US and other liberal countries, it takes guts standing against homosexuality.  But in Georgia where being Orthodox Christian is the norm, even the patriarch does not require guts.  Guts would be standing against the status quo in a society.

Apparently in Georgia, the Church is not supported by the state--at the insistence of the Catholicos Patriarch. The patriarch is standing against the leaders of the state, who are pandering to Europe.
Does that lessen my argument somehow?  Is the Church a minority?  Is the Church a weak body in the country?

And should the Church of Georgia sanction gay pride parades? Shall it allow the state to destroy its traditional culture (that is, communism all over again)?

People were hurt. That was unfortunate, and possibly wrong (do we know the actual circumstances? What is the evidence? Do we condemn based off news reports and hearsay?).

This isn't to comment on this case, but when Christians are confronted by blasphemy, even the response of the holy is not bashful.

Arius uttered blasphemy. St. Nicholas smacked him. Men punished St. Nicholas and protected Arius. But God Himself restored St. Nicholas to his office as one not worthy of condemnation because Arius was deserving of rebuke.
What r u smoking? Where is the blasphemy? Where did anybody ask the patriarch's blessing for a gay parade? The Church, as in hierarchy, ought, more fittingly, not intervene in this. Really.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: minasoliman on May 18, 2013, 12:24:06 PM
you'd, one thinks, know that to be part of  mob no extraordinary amount of guts is required. more guts were required for the few gay people to walk around surrounded by that mob.

I'm referring to Patriarch Ilia and other figures like the mayor of Moscow who have come out against gay rallies. They have more guts than the chickens over in Western Europe.

In Georgia?  Is Georgia really that liberal for the patriarch to show "bravery" in taking a stand?  Isn't Orthodox Christianity the state sponsored religion?

Devin, yes, here in the US and other liberal countries, it takes guts standing against homosexuality.  But in Georgia where being Orthodox Christian is the norm, even the patriarch does not require guts.  Guts would be standing against the status quo in a society.

Apparently in Georgia, the Church is not supported by the state--at the insistence of the Catholicos Patriarch. The patriarch is standing against the leaders of the state, who are pandering to Europe.
Does that lessen my argument somehow?  Is the Church a minority?  Is the Church a weak body in the country?

And should the Church of Georgia sanction gay pride parades? Shall it allow the state to destroy its traditional culture (that is, communism all over again)?

People were hurt. That was unfortunate, and possibly wrong (do we know the actual circumstances? What is the evidence? Do we condemn based off news reports and hearsay?).

This isn't to comment on this case, but when Christians are confronted by blasphemy, even the response of the holy is not bashful.

Arius uttered blasphemy. St. Nicholas smacked him. Men punished St. Nicholas and protected Arius. But God Himself restored St. Nicholas to his office as one not worthy of condemnation because Arius was deserving of rebuke.

I'm not saying you shouldn't stand against sins.  But with what happened, with the videos shown, the Church should take a stand against this violence.  They can balance it with condemnation of homosexuality, but perhaps there should be a way to change their approach to protests, so that things like this won't happen again.  Otherwise, you actually are doing exactly what the opposition wants, that is to make them look like martyrs.  It's the glory and driving force of a movement.

Why are you bringing up the story of St. Nicholas?  Why the double talk?  First you say we can't verify that this is Church-sponsored violence and now you're bringing up the story that makes it look like the Church-sponsored violence can be justified.  Perhaps we should dogmatize the story and make it canonical for bishops to go and punch heretics and sinners.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: 88Devin12 on May 18, 2013, 12:48:06 PM
(also, just fyi, I don't mean strong as in good or moral)

Still..."strength" is quite a stretch, especially when you want to consider the spiritual understanding of true strength.

Is it really "strength" for a mob President to use the mob to hush his opponents?

Leaders like Hitler, Stalin and others could all be considered strong leaders, despite the terrible things they did.

A good leader is different than a strong leader.

Hitler and Stalin are weak leaders to me.  In their insecurities, they killed the masses so that they give an illusion of strength.

My spiritual father taught me a lesson.  Which is stronger?  To hate your enemies, or to love them?  Then you'll know, "leaders" like Hitler and Stalin were the weakest.

I'm not talking about strong in terms of faith. If you want to talk about leaders strong in faith, we can talk about St. Justinian, St. Sava and his father St. Stefan, St. Vladimir the Great and others.

Memories of these men live on as inspirations, while the memories of Stalin and Hitler will live on as damnworthy.  If only making long-lasting memories gives someone strength, then the saints as much as the tyrants are equally strong.  I make no distinction, even on a moral level, let alone spiritual.  Tyrants withered away time and again, which only proves their inherent weaknesses, not strengths.

Ever hear of Genghis Khan or Kublai Khan? They committed what is equivalent in modern days to genocide, yet they aren't remembered as damnworthy leaders. What Stalin & Hitler did was absolutely terrible, but longer-term history has a tendency to change perspectives of leaders many years after.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Shanghaiski on May 18, 2013, 12:54:16 PM
Eh, history depends on the historian. The Mongols like Genghis Khan. The Greeks like Alexander the Great. The Arabs, not so much for both.

Not that anyone here would probably agree, but Hitler and Stalin are really very different leaders. Hitler was motivated by ideology so much that it blinded him. Stalin was not so motivated, I don't think. His rule suggests a certain amount of pragmatism. (Interestingly, after Hitler's invasion of the USSR, Stalin's officers visited him at his dacha. Stalin thought, after hearing the news, that they had come to arrest him. Instead, they had come to ask what his orders were.)
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: NicholasMyra on May 18, 2013, 01:00:08 PM
Perhaps their elected representatives leave them no choice but to express their will in this manner.
But we're talking about Christians here, not pagans.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Romaios on May 18, 2013, 01:17:34 PM
Perhaps their elected representatives leave them no choice but to express their will in this manner.
But we're talking about Christians here, not pagans.

Are we? I wouldn't bet on it. Most people in our countries are nominally Orthodox, but definitely not sympathetic to gay people. If such a protest were to happen here, I'm sure that lots of homophobic thugs would jump at the chance to bash the gay, with or without patriarchal blessing. So the fact that some clergy were involved doesn't mean that the anti-parade was staged to happen like this by the Church. Things were bound to get out of control once the mob was unleashed.   
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: NicholasMyra on May 18, 2013, 01:29:02 PM
Fair enough.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Elpidophoros on May 18, 2013, 02:34:17 PM
If you say, peaceful protest is the current prevailing political correctness,yes I agree;but if you think it's the only "orthodox way",I do not think so.
At least no one was killed in the anti-homosexual riots,but Agia Theodosia the  Konstantinoupolitissa literally KILLED a man(who was just following orders )by her very hands to protest the policy of Leo the Iauros.And the Church canonized her as a Saint.How do you explain this?
   
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: minasoliman on May 18, 2013, 02:40:24 PM
If you say, peaceful protest is the current prevailing political correctness,yes I agree;but if you think it's the only "orthodox way",I do not think so.
At least no one was killed in the anti-homosexual riots,but Agia Theodosia the  Konstantinoupolitissa literally KILLED a man(who was just following orders )by her very hands to protest the policy of Leo the Iauros.And the Church canonized her as a Saint.How do you explain this?
   

Why do you venerate her?  This isn't a rhetorical question, this is an honest one.

Why we venerate people like St. Constantine or St. Augustine?  Or for the previous comment, why St. Nicholas as well?
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: augustin717 on May 18, 2013, 02:41:35 PM
If you say, peaceful protest is the current prevailing political correctness,yes I agree;but if you think it's the only "orthodox way",I do not think so.
At least no one was killed in the anti-homosexual riots,but Agia Theodosia the  Konstantinoupolitissa literally KILLED a man(who was just following orders )by her very hands to protest the policy of Leo the Iauros.And the Church canonized her as a Saint.How do you explain this?
   
Perhaps we've-most of us,at least-evolved somehow since then

tags editted - MK
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: ialmisry on May 18, 2013, 02:47:31 PM
If you say, peaceful protest is the current prevailing political correctness,yes I agree;but if you think it's the only "orthodox way",I do not think so.
At least no one was killed in the anti-homosexual riots,but Agia Theodosia the  Konstantinoupolitissa literally KILLED a man(who was just following orders )by her very hands to protest the policy of Leo the Iauros.And the Church canonized her as a Saint.How do you explain this?
   

Why do you venerate her?  This isn't a rhetorical question, this is an honest one.

Why we venerate people like St. Constantine or St. Augustine?  Or for the previous comment, why St. Nicholas as well?
Because God has glorified them.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: 88Devin12 on May 18, 2013, 02:47:34 PM
If you say, peaceful protest is the current prevailing political correctness,yes I agree;but if you think it's the only "orthodox way",I do not think so.
At least no one was killed in the anti-homosexual riots,but Agia Theodosia the  Konstantinoupolitissa literally KILLED a man(who was just following orders )by her very hands to protest the policy of Leo the Iauros.And the Church canonized her as a Saint.How do you explain this?
   

Why do you venerate her?  This isn't a rhetorical question, this is an honest one.

Why we venerate people like St. Constantine or St. Augustine?

why not? the church has recognized that God has glorified them. The path to heaven is narrow, but that doesn't mean there is only one narrow path. Martyrs being one example, the monastic ascetic life being another, and married ascetic life being another.

I've still been trying to read the Brother's Karamazov. While it is fiction, it still is very reflective of Russian thought and life at the time. In the story, Elder Zosima dies and his body almost immediately starts smelling of corruption, which leads everyone (except his closest friends and the more learned monks) to assume he is in hell. Yet of course, that (the incorruption of a body) is just one sign of his holiness, neither is the "yellow bones" as put forward by other monks in the novel. Many of our Saints' relics are bare bones, including Biblical figures we know are glorified.

Just as in that illustration, there are multiple, narrow paths to heaven. One doesn't just have to be a hermit in the desert of Egypt, the forested mountains of Greece or the tundra of Russia. One can be a soldier who has killed people in warfare, but who is killed by his army for being a Christian. Certainly, many of the Apostles probably didn't experience the light as some later spiritual elders experienced, yet they still attained the kingdom. Look at Dismas as another example, a murderer, a criminal who was justly condemned, but who, at his death, repented to God himself who hung next to him, and was saved.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: ialmisry on May 18, 2013, 02:49:13 PM
Eh, history depends on the historian. The Mongols like Genghis Khan. The Greeks like Alexander the Great. The Arabs, not so much for both.
Actually we, Christian and Muslim, like Alexander a lot.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: ialmisry on May 18, 2013, 02:50:49 PM
you'd, one thinks, know that to be part of  mob no extraordinary amount of guts is required. more guts were required for the few gay people to walk around surrounded by that mob.

I'm referring to Patriarch Ilia and other figures like the mayor of Moscow who have come out against gay rallies. They have more guts than the chickens over in Western Europe.

In Georgia?  Is Georgia really that liberal for the patriarch to show "bravery" in taking a stand?  Isn't Orthodox Christianity the state sponsored religion?

Devin, yes, here in the US and other liberal countries, it takes guts standing against homosexuality.  But in Georgia where being Orthodox Christian is the norm, even the patriarch does not require guts.  Guts would be standing against the status quo in a society.

Apparently in Georgia, the Church is not supported by the state--at the insistence of the Catholicos Patriarch. The patriarch is standing against the leaders of the state, who are pandering to Europe.
Does that lessen my argument somehow?  Is the Church a minority?  Is the Church a weak body in the country?

And should the Church of Georgia sanction gay pride parades? Shall it allow the state to destroy its traditional culture (that is, communism all over again)?

People were hurt. That was unfortunate, and possibly wrong (do we know the actual circumstances? What is the evidence? Do we condemn based off news reports and hearsay?).

This isn't to comment on this case, but when Christians are confronted by blasphemy, even the response of the holy is not bashful.

Arius uttered blasphemy. St. Nicholas smacked him. Men punished St. Nicholas and protected Arius. But God Himself restored St. Nicholas to his office as one not worthy of condemnation because Arius was deserving of rebuke.
What r u smoking? Where is the blasphemy? Where did anybody ask the patriarch's blessing for a gay parade? The Church, as in hierarchy, ought, more fittingly, not intervene in this. Really.
Why not?
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Shanghaiski on May 18, 2013, 02:56:09 PM
Eh, history depends on the historian. The Mongols like Genghis Khan. The Greeks like Alexander the Great. The Arabs, not so much for both.
Actually we, Christian and Muslim, like Alexander a lot.

Really? Hmmm, then that would mean the BBC was wrong! Oh no!
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Shanghaiski on May 18, 2013, 02:56:59 PM
you'd, one thinks, know that to be part of  mob no extraordinary amount of guts is required. more guts were required for the few gay people to walk around surrounded by that mob.

I'm referring to Patriarch Ilia and other figures like the mayor of Moscow who have come out against gay rallies. They have more guts than the chickens over in Western Europe.

In Georgia?  Is Georgia really that liberal for the patriarch to show "bravery" in taking a stand?  Isn't Orthodox Christianity the state sponsored religion?

Devin, yes, here in the US and other liberal countries, it takes guts standing against homosexuality.  But in Georgia where being Orthodox Christian is the norm, even the patriarch does not require guts.  Guts would be standing against the status quo in a society.

Apparently in Georgia, the Church is not supported by the state--at the insistence of the Catholicos Patriarch. The patriarch is standing against the leaders of the state, who are pandering to Europe.
Does that lessen my argument somehow?  Is the Church a minority?  Is the Church a weak body in the country?

And should the Church of Georgia sanction gay pride parades? Shall it allow the state to destroy its traditional culture (that is, communism all over again)?

People were hurt. That was unfortunate, and possibly wrong (do we know the actual circumstances? What is the evidence? Do we condemn based off news reports and hearsay?).

This isn't to comment on this case, but when Christians are confronted by blasphemy, even the response of the holy is not bashful.

Arius uttered blasphemy. St. Nicholas smacked him. Men punished St. Nicholas and protected Arius. But God Himself restored St. Nicholas to his office as one not worthy of condemnation because Arius was deserving of rebuke.
What r u smoking? Where is the blasphemy? Where did anybody ask the patriarch's blessing for a gay parade? The Church, as in hierarchy, ought, more fittingly, not intervene in this. Really.
Why not?

Because they need to concentrate on being irrelevant.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: mike on May 18, 2013, 03:55:59 PM
As far as I know, most of the demonstrators against it were not violent, nor did His Holiness and Beatitude advocate violence.

Some proofs?

People were hurt. That was unfortunate, and possibly wrong

You have just gained another one level in lack of conscience.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: minasoliman on May 18, 2013, 03:59:57 PM
Isa, Devin, thank you for the posts, but you did not answer my question.  I did not ask why we should not venerate them.  I asked why are they venerated?  Or better yet, why did God glorify them?

And I'm not saying they shouldn't be venerated.  I'm looking for a different answers for each saint.

Why is Adam, Jacob, Moses, David, Solomon, etc. all venerated, all glorified?  Was every part of their existence infallible?
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: minasoliman on May 18, 2013, 04:15:23 PM
I also wanted to see what Elpidiphoros' answer would be as well.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Gunnarr on May 18, 2013, 04:40:43 PM
You are mostly missing Michal's point. Metropolitan Hilarion of the MP wrote a blogpost several years ago about the fragility of Orthodoxy in pre-Revolutionary Russia and his fear about the possible course of the future of its post communist revival. I couldn't find the original link, it was a thread years ago, but I found this excerpt, relevant here:

"(Metropolitan Hilarion) warns against a type of reactionary Orthodoxy that I see all too much of in the news:

The second danger is that. of militant Orthodoxy, which would be a post-atheist counterpart of militant atheism. I mean an Orthodoxy that fights against Jews, against masons, against democracy, against Western culture, against enlightenment. This type of Orthodoxy is being preached even by some key members of the hierarchy, and it has many supporters within the Church."

http://livingtext.wordpress.com/category/orthodoxy/

Except you leave out everything before, where he talks about how the rise of atheism came about BECAUSE of the enlightenment ideals, causing even the church itself to lose much of its values and become secularized. And, pointing out, even today it is happening in the Russian church especially with the laity who are brought up in such "western" mindsets. ( I would argue it is happening in all the churches) Of course, the blogger you linked to laments there was no reformation in Russia. And points out, after the quote you said claims

 "Perhaps there are movements within Russia that are moving ad fontes back to the Scriptures, but what I see is a reactionary movement that glories in the past and believe in a crystalized version of unchanging doctrine. I believe all this is greatly to the disadvantage of the Russian Church and nation. May God grant them more light and the ability to change where they need to."

Reactionary movement that glories in the past and BELIEVE IN A CRYSTALIZED VERSION OF UNCHANGING DOCTRINE

This brings up a good point, there seems to be many in the Orthodox Church today who are against unchanging doctrine, instead are for changing it! (largely just to fit the mold of the "enlightened" ideals they were taught in secular schools...)



Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Orthodox11 on May 18, 2013, 05:06:37 PM
I know some of the hard-line priests who led the counter protest. They're kind and sincere people and their hearts are certainly in the right place, though I don't agree with their methods or some of their opinions.

Patriarch Ilia belongs to a much more moderate trend within the Georgian Church, and anyone who knows him would find the idea that he would be in favour of violent opposition absurd.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Gunnarr on May 18, 2013, 05:21:39 PM
Patriarch Ilia belongs to a much more moderate trend within the Georgian Church, and anyone who knows him would find the idea that he would be in favour of violent opposition absurd.

I agree with this assessment. I have heard Patriarch Ilia also condemned the violence, but I cannot find a source. I am not too good at finding any releases from the georgian church.

I also agree with Patriarch Ilia being a moderate, seeing as he left the World Council of "Churches", albiet only because many of the most prestigious monasteries threatened to cease commemoration of him unless he left the organization.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: NicholasMyra on May 18, 2013, 05:22:14 PM
How do you explain this?

Why is Adam, Jacob, Moses, David, Solomon, etc. all venerated, all glorified?  Was every part of their existence infallible?

Those people were set aside for the purposes of God. That's what holy means.

We aren't methodists. Being a saint doesn't mean that person was "physically strong, mentally awake, and morally straight" or whatever.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: minasoliman on May 18, 2013, 07:49:59 PM
How do you explain this?

Why is Adam, Jacob, Moses, David, Solomon, etc. all venerated, all glorified?  Was every part of their existence infallible?

Those people were set aside for the purposes of God. That's what holy means.

We aren't methodists. Being a saint doesn't mean that person was "physically strong, mentally awake, and morally straight" or whatever.
Exactly!  Couldn't have said it better. I'm amazed that no one else could answer this though.

So now, since we got the point across that they had a special purpose with God and that they weren't always morally straight, then why bring up events of killing and shortcomings of a saint, as if they're justified?  What's the purpose of talking about St. Theodosia killing an iconoclast?  Does that mean that because a saint did it, it makes it right?

I'm trying to challenge the reason behind those who bring up saints that did wrong things as if they're right. It worries me if that's really what they're venerated for.  Might as well make justifications for collateral damage in wars because the old testament seems to have allowed it as a military side-product.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: NightOwl on May 18, 2013, 08:16:36 PM
Amazing how some people seem to think they know what's best for the Georgian nation more than the much-loved Patriarch of Georgia...
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Kerdy on May 18, 2013, 08:45:52 PM
Then I'd like to see them come out and condemn the violence that happened. 

As would I. 

I'd like to see some of those priests provide for the well-being of those injured and killed. 

In what way?  Unless they are doctors or nurses, what could they provide?  Spiritual support?  Doubtful they would want to even see the priest.

A father may have not told his son to go and throw stones, but when a son goes and throws stones, the father is still responsible.

In no way is your statement even remotely accurate.  Grown men are responsible for themselves.  If they were of school age, they should be home.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Kerdy on May 18, 2013, 08:54:34 PM
you'd, one thinks, know that to be part of  mob no extraordinary amount of guts is required. more guts were required for the few gay people to walk around surrounded by that mob.

I'm referring to Patriarch Ilia and other figures like the mayor of Moscow who have come out against gay rallies. They have more guts than the chickens over in Western Europe.

In Georgia?  Is Georgia really that liberal for the patriarch to show "bravery" in taking a stand?  Isn't Orthodox Christianity the state sponsored religion?

Devin, yes, here in the US and other liberal countries, it takes guts standing against homosexuality.  But in Georgia where being Orthodox Christian is the norm, even the patriarch does not require guts.  Guts would be standing against the status quo in a society.

Apparently in Georgia, the Church is not supported by the state--at the insistence of the Catholicos Patriarch. The patriarch is standing against the leaders of the state, who are pandering to Europe.
Does that lessen my argument somehow?  Is the Church a minority?  Is the Church a weak body in the country?

And should the Church of Georgia sanction gay pride parades? Shall it allow the state to destroy its traditional culture (that is, communism all over again)?

People were hurt. That was unfortunate, and possibly wrong (do we know the actual circumstances? What is the evidence? Do we condemn based off news reports and hearsay?).

This isn't to comment on this case, but when Christians are confronted by blasphemy, even the response of the holy is not bashful.

Arius uttered blasphemy. St. Nicholas smacked him. Men punished St. Nicholas and protected Arius. But God Himself restored St. Nicholas to his office as one not worthy of condemnation because Arius was deserving of rebuke.
What r u smoking? Where is the blasphemy? Where did anybody ask the patriarch's blessing for a gay parade? The Church, as in hierarchy, ought, more fittingly, not intervene in this. Really.
Why not?
Because people have, foolishly in my opinion, decided the Church should have no influence on politics and as a result, be completely hands off.  What they fail to understand is, as a Christian we are called to live every aspect of our life in that capacity, including politics.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Kerdy on May 18, 2013, 08:58:14 PM
Amazing how some people seem to think they know what's best for the Georgian nation more than the much-loved Patriarch of Georgia...

Good point.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: minasoliman on May 18, 2013, 09:04:02 PM
Then I'd like to see them come out and condemn the violence that happened. 

As would I. 

I'd like to see some of those priests provide for the well-being of those injured and killed. 

In what way?  Unless they are doctors or nurses, what could they provide?  Spiritual support?  Doubtful they would want to even see the priest.

A father may have not told his son to go and throw stones, but when a son goes and throws stones, the father is still responsible.

In no way is your statement even remotely accurate.  Grown men are responsible for themselves.  If they were of school age, they should be home.

In some financial way.  If they were implicated in the stone throwing and the violence, they have to pay.

Well, then, if they are grown men, excommunicate them until they repent.  This way, the Church would be clear they will not tolerate anyone who in walking with the priests and bishops in the protests become violent.

But if they're silent, then they are responsible for their actions based on their silence.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Shanghaiski on May 18, 2013, 09:26:48 PM
As far as I know, most of the demonstrators against it were not violent, nor did His Holiness and Beatitude advocate violence.

Some proofs?

People were hurt. That was unfortunate, and possibly wrong

You have just gained another one level in lack of conscience.

Thanks. God bless you, too.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Kerdy on May 18, 2013, 09:39:26 PM
In some financial way.  If they were implicated in the stone throwing and the violence, they have to pay.


The parents?  No.  People are responsible for their own actions when they are adults.  If they were not adults, the parents are only responsible when it is proven they were in some way involved in the child doing the wrong action.  If I have a teenage son who is busted for selling drugs, I don’t go to jail unless I put him up to it.  Same thing.

Well, then, if they are grown men, excommunicate them until they repent.  This way, the Church would be clear they will not tolerate anyone who in walking with the priests and bishops in the protests become violent.

This has nothing to do with what I addressed and has nothing to do with us.  We do not dictate Church policy.  I leave that to those in proper position.

But if they're silent, then they are responsible for their actions based on their silence.

No.  Apathy does not always equal guilt.  Silence does not always equal apathy.  And as someone has already pointed out, we don’t have the full story.  What is the background/history?  What events lead up to this?  Are the clips of footage we are able to see ALL of the video or is there something important we are missing?  We don’t have all the answers which is why I stated previously if the protestors initiated the violence they are wrong.

We also are all very well aware of mob mentality.  When a few get stupid, others who are emotionally charged follow their lead.  Most likely, there was only a small percentage of violent protestors.  This does not make it right, but without all of the information, we only guess.  

This is a single isolated event.  If Orthodox Christians the world over were attacking people, it would be different, but they are not.

This has nothing to do with what I addressed and has nothing to do with us.  We do not dictate Church policy.

But if they're silent, then they are responsible for their actions based on their silence.

No.  Apathy does not always equal guilt.  
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: minasoliman on May 18, 2013, 09:45:21 PM
Quote
The parents?  No.  People are responsible for their own actions when they are adults.  If they were not adults, the parents are only responsible when it is proven they were in some way involved in the child doing the wrong action.  If I have a teenage son who is busted for selling drugs, I don’t go to jail unless I put him up to it.  Same thing.

I said if it's been shown the priests were implicit in this, then yes, they should provide.

Quote
This has nothing to do with what I addressed and has nothing to do with us.  We do not dictate Church policy.  I leave that to those in proper position.

I disagree.  It has everything to do with what you addressed.  If they are grown men, which I doubt by the way they act and what they said, then the Church should be quick to carry the big stick.  In fact, according to the articles here, many of the protesters have said they were inspired by Patriarch Ilia to go and protest.  Already, his name is invoked in the violence.  If Patriarch Ilia is silent, how does this make him look like?

Grown men wouldn't hide behind the patriarch's name in their violent actions.  Grown men would take responsibility for their own actions.  Because they do this in the name of their Church and their culture, the Church must act.


And let's not ignore this because it's an isolated incident.  What makes us different and responsible Christians is that we should be quick to condemn even isolated incidents. 
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Kerdy on May 18, 2013, 09:57:57 PM

I said if it's been shown the priests were implicit in this, then yes, they should provide.
 

I misunderstood.  If the priests promoted violence, this would be a problem, depending on the full story.

I disagree.  It has everything to do with what you addressed.  If they are grown men, which I doubt by the way they act and what they said, then the Church should be quick to carry the big stick.  In fact, according to the articles here, many of the protesters have said they were inspired by Patriarch Ilia to go and protest.  Already, his name is invoked in the violence.  If Patriarch Ilia is silent, how does this make him look like?
 

Of course they were inspired to protest, but this does not mean they were asked to hurt anyone.  I doubt his name invokes violence.  More likely people who were predisposed to be violent used this as an excuse.  He should make a statement of some sort, but I think we should give him a little more time to prepare the proper statement.  After all, whatever he says will be scrutinized.  I imagine he is already working on a response.

Grown men wouldn't hide behind the patriarch's name in their violent actions.  Grown men would take responsibility for their own actions.  Because they do this in the name of their Church and their culture, the Church must act.
 

Sure they do.  History proves different.  No one wants to be responsible for their own actions any longer.  Again, I do not know the complete history regarding this situation so I can’t get into that much detail.  What would you like to see as the Church’s response?

And let's not ignore this because it's an isolated incident.  What makes us different and responsible Christians is that we should be quick to condemn even isolated incidents. 

I didn’t say we shouldn’t.  My point was this is not the norm so over reacting is as bad as not reacting. 


Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: minasoliman on May 18, 2013, 10:25:12 PM

I said if it's been shown the priests were implicit in this, then yes, they should provide.
 

I misunderstood.  If the priests promoted violence, this would be a problem, depending on the full story.

I disagree.  It has everything to do with what you addressed.  If they are grown men, which I doubt by the way they act and what they said, then the Church should be quick to carry the big stick.  In fact, according to the articles here, many of the protesters have said they were inspired by Patriarch Ilia to go and protest.  Already, his name is invoked in the violence.  If Patriarch Ilia is silent, how does this make him look like?
 

Of course they were inspired to protest, but this does not mean they were asked to hurt anyone.  I doubt his name invokes violence.  More likely people who were predisposed to be violent used this as an excuse.  He should make a statement of some sort, but I think we should give him a little more time to prepare the proper statement.  After all, whatever he says will be scrutinized.  I imagine he is already working on a response.

Grown men wouldn't hide behind the patriarch's name in their violent actions.  Grown men would take responsibility for their own actions.  Because they do this in the name of their Church and their culture, the Church must act.
 

Sure they do.  History proves different.  No one wants to be responsible for their own actions any longer.  Again, I do not know the complete history regarding this situation so I can’t get into that much detail.  What would you like to see as the Church’s response?

And let's not ignore this because it's an isolated incident.  What makes us different and responsible Christians is that we should be quick to condemn even isolated incidents. 

I didn’t say we shouldn’t.  My point was this is not the norm so over reacting is as bad as not reacting. 




Fair enough...

If this is the first time violent protests took place after invoking the good name of the patriarch, the Church can perhaps issue a warning that anyone who would do this again would be excommunicated. Any priest who participated in the violence should be deposed.  These reports of carrying nettles by the priests sends a bad message to the protesters, and it's inexcusable.

The church can continue to make clear that homosexuality is unacceptable, against church morals and Georgian values and culture. The Church should also reiterate its stand to excommunicate anyone who thinks homosexuality is acceptable and moral behavior. But the violent reactions of Orthodox Christians go against the commission of the gospel to spread peace, and wherever peace is rejected, let it return to you. Where Christians incite violence and not peace is inexcusable. The church should encourage that those responsible for the damage of properties and injuries of people should take responsibility and recompensate for them.  Only then would it be acceptable for proper penance to bring back communicants to the Church.

I think this message would serve the Church well and fairly.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: mike on May 19, 2013, 11:22:10 AM
No.  Apathy does not always equal guilt.  Silence does not always equal apathy.  And as someone has already pointed out, we don’t have the full story.  What is the background/history?  What events lead up to this?  Are the clips of footage we are able to see ALL of the video or is there something important we are missing?  We don’t have all the answers which is why I stated previously if the protestors initiated the violence they are wrong.

We also are all very well aware of mob mentality.  When a few get stupid, others who are emotionally charged follow their lead.  Most likely, there was only a small percentage of violent protestors.  This does not make it right, but without all of the information, we only guess. 

This is a single isolated event.  If Orthodox Christians the world over were attacking people, it would be different, but they are not.

(https://encrypted-tbn1.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcRqrhbNQ6nsHBRc5Z_2e1n5h2ADH9oD3S4LvVwyny_8wnUoMHakUg)
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: ativan on May 19, 2013, 05:20:04 PM
Some orthodox people wary too much about my people's "unorthodox" behavior. Save yourself energy for the future and I will tell you one thing: every time this type of parade will be planned it will meet the same fate. In fact, they, power much higher above, have tried to conduct such parades several times before (at least two times that I know of) and each time these gathering collapsed. We, Georgians, might be cruel, uneducated and barbarian orthodox people but how come those clever and humane beings failed to see that if this thing failed several times before it would fail again? They know it but they persevere. Why?

For the records, no gay is persecuted in Georgia. Gays have lived there long time and the had much gayer life when they wanted. They have gay clubs and no one has exploded those. We just don't want our next generation fall into that sin, that's all. And little bit of violence will help this. Gay people must see it, that every time their attempt to expose their parades in open it will be met by opposition from Georgian people.

After all if you all say gay people should have right to do this and that why straight Georgian's, which is perhaps over 99 %, should not have their rights defended? We, over 99 %, don't want such parades and for the sake of democracy, if such a thing really exists in nature, respect our decision. We on the other hand promise that as it was before we are not going to break in their houses or clubs and bit them. Just do it in private.

BTW below is a youtube link to one of those gay pride parades in 2012 (under the name of "say no to homophobia") from last year:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cK2qjGprS10 (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cK2qjGprS10)
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: NicholasMyra on May 19, 2013, 09:02:22 PM
We just don't want our next generation fall into that sin, that's all. And little bit of violence will help this.
Will you at least stop doing it in the name of Christ? Maybe there is a local Georgian tribal war deity who would be a better substitute.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Andrew21091 on May 19, 2013, 10:45:27 PM
And little bit of violence will help this.

"In the End Days a man will be saved by love, humbleness and kindness. Kindness will open the gates of Heaven; humbleness will lead into the Heaven; a man, whose heart is filled with love, will see the God." - St. Gabriel of Mtskheta

Sorry, I don't see any love, humbleness, or kindness in the video you posted or in the actions of the protesters.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Kerdy on May 19, 2013, 11:04:56 PM
No.  Apathy does not always equal guilt.  Silence does not always equal apathy.  And as someone has already pointed out, we don’t have the full story.  What is the background/history?  What events lead up to this?  Are the clips of footage we are able to see ALL of the video or is there something important we are missing?  We don’t have all the answers which is why I stated previously if the protestors initiated the violence they are wrong.

We also are all very well aware of mob mentality.  When a few get stupid, others who are emotionally charged follow their lead.  Most likely, there was only a small percentage of violent protestors.  This does not make it right, but without all of the information, we only guess. 

This is a single isolated event.  If Orthodox Christians the world over were attacking people, it would be different, but they are not.

(https://encrypted-tbn1.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcRqrhbNQ6nsHBRc5Z_2e1n5h2ADH9oD3S4LvVwyny_8wnUoMHakUg)
I could post meaningless photos as well in response posts as if they provided some sort of impact, but prefer to conduct myself in a mature manner.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: minasoliman on May 20, 2013, 12:47:57 AM
We just don't want our next generation fall into that sin, that's all. And little bit of violence will help this.
Will you at least stop doing it in the name of Christ? Maybe there is a local Georgian tribal war deity who would be a better substitute.
+1

It's people like these that should be excommunicated.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: 88Devin12 on May 20, 2013, 01:06:23 AM
We just don't want our next generation fall into that sin, that's all. And little bit of violence will help this.
Will you at least stop doing it in the name of Christ? Maybe there is a local Georgian tribal war deity who would be a better substitute.
+1

It's people like these that should be excommunicated.

along with people in active homosexual relationships and heterosexuals in non-marital sexual relationships.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: ativan on May 20, 2013, 03:14:43 AM
We just don't want our next generation fall into that sin, that's all. And little bit of violence will help this.
Will you at least stop doing it in the name of Christ? Maybe there is a local Georgian tribal war deity who would be a better substitute.
Incarnated Son of God Himself cleansed the Temple of money changers. God the Father Himself destroyed Sodom and Gomorrah. I don't think any of us loves human being more then Creator Himself does.

Saint king of Georgia David the builder cleansed the Church of gay priests and likes and he was very cruel against them. He did it in the name of Christ. We can't even come closer to his sainthood.

There's a lot of misrepresentation of Orthodoxy going on today. Christian first of all is supposed to be a solider of Christ.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: ativan on May 20, 2013, 03:21:52 AM
And little bit of violence will help this.

"In the End Days a man will be saved by love, humbleness and kindness. Kindness will open the gates of Heaven; humbleness will lead into the Heaven; a man, whose heart is filled with love, will see the God." - St. Gabriel of Mtskheta

Sorry, I don't see any love, humbleness, or kindness in the video you posted or in the actions of the protesters.
Father Gabriel said and thought many other things that might come as a surprise to you. Believe or not he also said: don't turn your the other chick and fight against those who slap you on one side.

Real question is: who loves gay people more? those who support their unchecked behavior and those who promote popularization of it or those who oppose it?
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: mike on May 20, 2013, 03:23:33 AM
Real question is: who loves gay people more? those who support their unchecked behavior and those who promote popularization of it or those who oppose it?

Those who try to rip them to shreds with bare hands propably.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Orthodox11 on May 20, 2013, 05:46:26 AM
(http://s020.radikal.ru/i706/1305/bd/d1a6ec8c1e1b.jpg)

(http://sphotos-h.ak.fbcdn.net/hphotos-ak-ash3/s720x720/945654_515743958485840_476788887_n.jpg)
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Kerdy on May 20, 2013, 06:22:44 AM
Real question is: who loves gay people more? those who support their unchecked behavior and those who promote popularization of it or those who oppose it?

Those who try to rip them to shreds with bare hands propably.
You know, sarcasm without appropriate, well thought out, intelligent responses is starting to lean me in the direction of “it may not have been as bad as you pretend”.  Keep up the good work.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Kerdy on May 20, 2013, 06:24:36 AM
We just don't want our next generation fall into that sin, that's all. And little bit of violence will help this.
Will you at least stop doing it in the name of Christ? Maybe there is a local Georgian tribal war deity who would be a better substitute.
Incarnated Son of God Himself cleansed the Temple of money changers. God the Father Himself destroyed Sodom and Gomorrah. I don't think any of us loves human being more then Creator Himself does.

Saint king of Georgia David the builder cleansed the Church of gay priests and likes and he was very cruel against them. He did it in the name of Christ. We can't even come closer to his sainthood.

There's a lot of misrepresentation of Orthodoxy going on today. Christian first of all is supposed to be a solider of Christ.

And little bit of violence will help this.

"In the End Days a man will be saved by love, humbleness and kindness. Kindness will open the gates of Heaven; humbleness will lead into the Heaven; a man, whose heart is filled with love, will see the God." - St. Gabriel of Mtskheta

Sorry, I don't see any love, humbleness, or kindness in the video you posted or in the actions of the protesters.
Father Gabriel said and thought many other things that might come as a surprise to you. Believe or not he also said: don't turn your the other chick and fight against those who slap you on one side.

Real question is: who loves gay people more? those who support their unchecked behavior and those who promote popularization of it or those who oppose it?

You bring up some interesting points.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Orthodox11 on May 20, 2013, 06:29:33 AM
There's a lot of misrepresentation of Orthodoxy going on today. Christian first of all is supposed to be a solider of Christ.

Sure, but being a soldier of Christ means entering into spiritual warfare against the devil and the passions. It does not mean using physical violence, especially when there's absolutely no need for it. The sword of the Christian is the Jesus Prayer, as the prayers for tonsuring a monk makes very clear.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: mike on May 20, 2013, 07:01:58 AM
Real question is: who loves gay people more? those who support their unchecked behavior and those who promote popularization of it or those who oppose it?

Those who try to rip them to shreds with bare hands propably.
You know, sarcasm without appropriate, well thought out, intelligent responses is starting to lean me in the direction of “it may not have been as bad as you pretend”.  Keep up the good work.

Have you watched the videos?
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: scamandrius on May 20, 2013, 07:31:12 AM
(http://s020.radikal.ru/i706/1305/bd/d1a6ec8c1e1b.jpg)

(http://sphotos-h.ak.fbcdn.net/hphotos-ak-ash3/s720x720/945654_515743958485840_476788887_n.jpg)

Good for you!  You know how to use photoshop!
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Orthodox11 on May 20, 2013, 07:32:50 AM
Good for you!  You know how to use photoshop!

I didn't make it, it's from Georgian media.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: minasoliman on May 20, 2013, 07:35:20 AM
We just don't want our next generation fall into that sin, that's all. And little bit of violence will help this.
Will you at least stop doing it in the name of Christ? Maybe there is a local Georgian tribal war deity who would be a better substitute.
+1

It's people like these that should be excommunicated.

along with people in active homosexual relationships and heterosexuals in non-marital sexual relationships.
I imagine the Church already excommunicated those if they already have people who religiously believe violence is the answer to wipe them off.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Kerdy on May 20, 2013, 07:50:02 AM
Real question is: who loves gay people more? those who support their unchecked behavior and those who promote popularization of it or those who oppose it?

Those who try to rip them to shreds with bare hands propably.
You know, sarcasm without appropriate, well thought out, intelligent responses is starting to lean me in the direction of “it may not have been as bad as you pretend”.  Keep up the good work.

Have you watched the videos?

Better than you have read my posts.

Or do you mean the one with a bunch of priests running from the violence?
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Kerdy on May 20, 2013, 07:53:41 AM
(http://s020.radikal.ru/i706/1305/bd/d1a6ec8c1e1b.jpg)

(http://sphotos-h.ak.fbcdn.net/hphotos-ak-ash3/s720x720/945654_515743958485840_476788887_n.jpg)

Good for you!  You know how to use photoshop!
What’s humorous is how an old man with a chair is compared to up-armored assault vehicles, tanks, men with body armor and military weapons and attack helicopters.  It’s overboard absurdity.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Orthodox11 on May 20, 2013, 07:55:39 AM
What’s humorous is how an old man with a chair is compared to up-armored assault vehicles, tanks, men with body armor and military weapons and attack helicopters.  It’s overboard absurdity.

There's a video of that old man using that chair to smash the windscreen of a bus carrying protesters. Of course it's overboard, that's the point.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Kerdy on May 20, 2013, 07:56:37 AM
What’s humorous is how an old man with a chair is compared to up-armored assault vehicles, tanks, men with body armor and military weapons and attack helicopters.  It’s overboard absurdity.

There's a video of that old man using that chair to smash the windscreen of a bus carrying protesters. Of course it's overboard, that's the point.

If he was going after the protesters and the protesters are the "bad guys", what’s the problem?

But let me get this right.  He smashes out a windshield and gets turned into a warmonger.  Border patrol agents get rocks hurled at them by the dozen, getting hit in the head, killed, and they shoot one person attempting to enter the country illegally as a result and the border patrol agents are evil.  I fail to see how the double standard actually works.

What am I missing?
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Orthodox11 on May 20, 2013, 08:00:04 AM
If he was going after the protesters and the protesters are the "bad guys", whats the problem?

The anti-homophobia protesters. Yes, they are the "bad guys" in so far as they're promoting sin. The problem is the unnecessary use of violence.

But let me get this right.  He smashes out a windshield and gets turned into a warmonger.  Border patrol agents get rocks hurled at them by the dozen, getting hit in the head, killed, and they shoot one person attempting to enter the country illegally as a result and the border patrol agents are evil.  I fail to see how the double standard actually works.

I don't know, I don't think I've ever mentioned border patrol agents.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: mike on May 20, 2013, 08:04:17 AM
Real question is: who loves gay people more? those who support their unchecked behavior and those who promote popularization of it or those who oppose it?

Those who try to rip them to shreds with bare hands propably.
You know, sarcasm without appropriate, well thought out, intelligent responses is starting to lean me in the direction of “it may not have been as bad as you pretend”.  Keep up the good work.

Have you watched the videos?

Better than you have read my posts.

Or do you mean the one with a bunch of priests running from the violence?

IMO they were running to the buses.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Kerdy on May 20, 2013, 08:04:22 AM
If he was going after the protesters and the protesters are the "bad guys", whats the problem?

The anti-homophobia protesters. Yes, they are the "bad guys" in so far as they're promoting sin. The problem is the unnecessary use of violence.

But let me get this right.  He smashes out a windshield and gets turned into a warmonger.  Border patrol agents get rocks hurled at them by the dozen, getting hit in the head, killed, and they shoot one person attempting to enter the country illegally as a result and the border patrol agents are evil.  I fail to see how the double standard actually works.

I don't know, I don't think I've ever mentioned border patrol agents.

So, he attacked the protesters you say are bad and he is vilified.  I am confused.  Should he not be honored?

You didn’t, just making a comparison to show the hypocrisy.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Kerdy on May 20, 2013, 08:05:14 AM
Real question is: who loves gay people more? those who support their unchecked behavior and those who promote popularization of it or those who oppose it?

Those who try to rip them to shreds with bare hands propably.
You know, sarcasm without appropriate, well thought out, intelligent responses is starting to lean me in the direction of “it may not have been as bad as you pretend”.  Keep up the good work.

Have you watched the videos?

Better than you have read my posts.

Or do you mean the one with a bunch of priests running from the violence?

IMO they were running to the buses.

Your opinion.  Have you even watched the videos?

Perhaps now you better understand what I have been saying in my posts about not having all the information.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Orthodox11 on May 20, 2013, 08:06:47 AM
So, he attacked the protesters you say are bad and he is vilified.  I am confused.  Should he not be honored?

No, unnecessary violent attacks should not be honoured even when they're perpetrated by the people on the right side of an argument.

Quote
You didn’t, just making a comparison to show the hypocrisy.

Whose hypocrisy?
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Kerdy on May 20, 2013, 08:08:34 AM
What’s humorous is how an old man with a chair is compared to up-armored assault vehicles, tanks, men with body armor and military weapons and attack helicopters.  It’s overboard absurdity.

There's a video of that old man using that chair to smash the windscreen of a bus carrying protesters. Of course it's overboard, that's the point.

I can't seem to find this video.  I saw a lot of smashing of windshields, but I didn't see him doing it.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: mike on May 20, 2013, 08:09:29 AM
Real question is: who loves gay people more? those who support their unchecked behavior and those who promote popularization of it or those who oppose it?

Those who try to rip them to shreds with bare hands propably.
You know, sarcasm without appropriate, well thought out, intelligent responses is starting to lean me in the direction of “it may not have been as bad as you pretend”.  Keep up the good work.

Have you watched the videos?

Better than you have read my posts.

Or do you mean the one with a bunch of priests running from the violence?

IMO they were running to the buses.

Your opinion.  Have you even watched the videos?

Perhaps now you better understand what I have been saying in my posts about not having all the information.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=7uC7VYF0NBI

Breaking the police lines and leading the charge.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Kerdy on May 20, 2013, 08:10:13 AM
No, unnecessary violent attacks should not be honoured even when they're perpetrated by the people on the right side of an argument.

I can respect your consistancy. 

Whose hypocrisy?

Everyones.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Orthodox11 on May 20, 2013, 08:10:26 AM
I can't seem to find this video.  I saw a lot of smashing of windshields, but I didn't see him doing it.

Here's one (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wvWQO27-fSc).
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Kerdy on May 20, 2013, 08:12:37 AM
Real question is: who loves gay people more? those who support their unchecked behavior and those who promote popularization of it or those who oppose it?

Those who try to rip them to shreds with bare hands propably.
You know, sarcasm without appropriate, well thought out, intelligent responses is starting to lean me in the direction of “it may not have been as bad as you pretend”.  Keep up the good work.

Have you watched the videos?

Better than you have read my posts.

Or do you mean the one with a bunch of priests running from the violence?

IMO they were running to the buses.

Your opinion.  Have you even watched the videos?

Perhaps now you better understand what I have been saying in my posts about not having all the information.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=7uC7VYF0NBI

Breaking the police lines and leading the charge.

Ok, still not seeing it.  I see a lot of people trying to get away from the violence.  Can you provide the specific second on the video?
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: mike on May 20, 2013, 08:14:36 AM
Police is blocking them from attacking buses. They are breaking the blockade.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Orthodox11 on May 20, 2013, 08:17:58 AM
In this speech (http://www.youtube.com/watch?NR=1&v=Aw56icxwDhk&feature=endscreen), Archbishop Jakob asks the policemen for forgiveness for breaking through their lines.

I actually agree with nearly everything he says. It's the use of violence that I have a problem with. A peaceful counter-protest was perfectly possible, especially when the number of nationalist counter-protesters dwarfed the tiny number of anti-homophobia protesters.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Kerdy on May 20, 2013, 08:25:30 AM
I can't seem to find this video.  I saw a lot of smashing of windshields, but I didn't see him doing it.

Here's one (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wvWQO27-fSc).
Ah-ha!  A video which appears to actually show something.  Thank you!  But I must confess...an old man barely swinging a chair at a hardened object which did not strike any person, and bounced off, hardly seems the threat he is being made out to be.  Had he whacked someone in the dome with it, now that would be different.  

Additionally, who was the person behind him to ran off with the chair?  Were they together?  The old fella was so much of a threat with his hulk like swing he didn’t even realize the chair was no longer in his grasp.  Understand, I am not debating the right or wrong of what he did, just the over the top vilification of the man.  It seems more like the shoe throwing type of thing done to Pres. Bush a few years ago.
I would like to see all of the video before I make a final decision, not just the media highlights.  I somehow doubt the parade folks showed up in a van and were immediately attacked.  It could have happened, but it seems unlikely.  And if they were, why?  Anyone have more video?
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Kerdy on May 20, 2013, 08:26:38 AM
Police is blocking them from attacking buses. They are breaking the blockade.

Yep, that is what I am seeing. ::)  I especially like the priest who gets out with the expression of relief only to walk to the side of the road.  He sure seemed like he was hell bent on hurting someone to me.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Kerdy on May 20, 2013, 08:28:07 AM
In this speech (http://www.youtube.com/watch?NR=1&v=Aw56icxwDhk&feature=endscreen), Archbishop Jakob asks the policemen for forgiveness for breaking through their lines.

I actually agree with nearly everything he says. It's the use of violence that I have a problem with. A peaceful counter-protest was perfectly possible, especially ...
A respectful position.  I do not find myself in disagreement.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: mike on May 20, 2013, 08:32:09 AM
In this speech (http://www.youtube.com/watch?NR=1&v=Aw56icxwDhk&feature=endscreen), Archbishop Jakob asks the policemen for forgiveness for breaking through their lines.

I actually agree with nearly everything he says. It's the use of violence that I have a problem with. A peaceful counter-protest was perfectly possible, especially ...
A respectful position.  I do not find myself in disagreement.

You say they did not break the lines or attack gays. He apologizes for breaking the lines. You say you agree with him.

Am I the only one who fails to see any logic?
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: stavros_388 on May 20, 2013, 08:34:09 AM
In this speech (http://www.youtube.com/watch?NR=1&v=Aw56icxwDhk&feature=endscreen), Archbishop Jakob asks the policemen for forgiveness for breaking through their lines.

I actually agree with nearly everything he says. It's the use of violence that I have a problem with. A peaceful counter-protest was perfectly possible, especially ...
A respectful position.  I do not find myself in disagreement.

You say they did not break the lines or attack gays. He apologizes for breaking the lines. You say you agree with him.

Am I the only one who fails to see any logic?

No, you're not.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: stavros_388 on May 20, 2013, 08:36:37 AM
Police is blocking them from attacking buses. They are breaking the blockade.

Yep, that is what I am seeing. ::)  I especially like the priest who gets out with the expression of relief only to walk to the side of the road.  He sure seemed like he was hell bent on hurting someone to me.

You have an uncanny ability to selectively see/read/hear whatever you think will strengthen your position, while filtering out anything that does not.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Kerdy on May 20, 2013, 08:38:15 AM
In this speech (http://www.youtube.com/watch?NR=1&v=Aw56icxwDhk&feature=endscreen), Archbishop Jakob asks the policemen for forgiveness for breaking through their lines.

I actually agree with nearly everything he says. It's the use of violence that I have a problem with. A peaceful counter-protest was perfectly possible, especially ...
A respectful position.  I do not find myself in disagreement.

You say they did not break the lines or attack gays. He apologizes for breaking the lines. You say you agree with him.

Am I the only one who fails to see any logic?

Your logic has several failures.  I never said the homosexuals were not attacked.  I also did not say anyone didn't brake police lines, only the video does not appear to show what you present, resulting in my additional comments about more video.  This proves you are not reading my posts.  
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Kerdy on May 20, 2013, 08:38:41 AM
Police is blocking them from attacking buses. They are breaking the blockade.

Yep, that is what I am seeing. ::)  I especially like the priest who gets out with the expression of relief only to walk to the side of the road.  He sure seemed like he was hell bent on hurting someone to me.

You have an uncanny ability to selectively see/read/hear whatever you think will strengthen your position, while filtering out anything that does not.

Like the videos themselves?  They are no different than showing only the few seconds where police shoot a suspect and ignore everything which leads up to that point.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: stavros_388 on May 20, 2013, 08:39:06 AM
There's a lot of misrepresentation of Orthodoxy going on today. Christian first of all is supposed to be a solider of Christ.

Sure, but being a soldier of Christ means entering into spiritual warfare against the devil and the passions. It does not mean using physical violence, especially when there's absolutely no need for it. The sword of the Christian is the Jesus Prayer, as the prayers for tonsuring a monk makes very clear.

Amen!
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Kerdy on May 20, 2013, 08:45:17 AM
It’s ok.  You can turn an old man who can hardly swing a chair into the criminal of the decade and ignore the public, blatant, “in your face” actions of the homosexuals who want to parade around and make fools of themselves.  It’s ok.  It’s what people do these days.  Cry for the evils of the world and spit at those who want better.  I really enjoy how people focus on actions of those who want no parade and ignore everything else.  A rational thinker would hope you would call out the wrongs on both sides, but perhaps that is asking too much from Christians these days.  I don’t know.  I am looking forward to the prostitutes pride parade where they hand out discount coupons.  Who thinks that is a good idea?  How about Drug Dealer Pride Parades?  Spouse abuser pride day anyone?  And you wonder why people feel the need to go as far as they do in protest.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: mike on May 20, 2013, 08:52:08 AM
Not "one man" but 30k.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Kerdy on May 20, 2013, 08:53:47 AM
Not "one man" but 30k.

I realize you have absolutely no idea why I am saying this, but thank you.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: mike on May 20, 2013, 08:54:48 AM
Not "one man" but 30k.

I realize you have absolutely no idea why I am saying this, but thank you.

I have some ideas but cannot share them in Public Fora.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Kerdy on May 20, 2013, 08:58:08 AM
Not "one man" but 30k.

I realize you have absolutely no idea why I am saying this, but thank you.

I have some ideas but cannot share them in Public Fora.

In that case, they are all incorrect.  If any were correct, you could easily share in the Public Fora.  With that, I leave this thread and it's tunnel vision. 

May the Lord have mercy on us all.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: NicholasMyra on May 20, 2013, 12:52:25 PM
Incarnated Son of God Himself cleansed the Temple of money changers.
He didn't incite a violent mob, he stirred up the animals and chased people around.

When an angry mob wanted to persecute a sexual sinner, he stopped them. Or do you not remember?

God the Father Himself destroyed Sodom and Gomorrah. I don't think any of us loves human being more then Creator Himself does.
"Beloved, never avenge yourselves, but leave it to the wrath of God, for it is written, 'Vengeance is mine, I will repay, says the Lord.”

"...the people did not receive him, because his face was set toward Jerusalem. And when his disciples James and John saw it, they said, 'Lord, do you want us to tell fire to come down from heaven and consume them?' But he turned and rebuked them."

Believe or not he also said: don't turn your the other chick and fight against those who slap you on one side.
Who cares?

Saint king of Georgia David the builder cleansed the Church of gay priests and likes and he was very cruel against them. He did it in the name of Christ. We can't even come closer to his sainthood.
"Saint' doesn't mean "morally right". We've been over this.

There's a lot of misrepresentation of Orthodoxy going on today. Christian first of all is supposed to be a solider of Christ.
I think you are confused about what that means. Perhaps being the soldier of one of your land's old gods would be more fitting:

(http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/0/02/Mithra_sacrifiant_le_Taureau-005.JPG/418px-Mithra_sacrifiant_le_Taureau-005.JPG)
One can have all the blood one wants.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Santagranddad on May 20, 2013, 03:21:06 PM
Sexual acts between people of the same sex is gravely sinful but nowhere in The New Testament is mob violence supported or condoned. Our Lord's actions and words in the Temple were considered and measured. No comparison can surely be made between the events in the Temple and Tbilisi?

While opposing the ever increasing demands of the Homosexual activist lobby, 'Queer bashing' is repellent. Trying to work out the sequence of events in Tbilisi even after watching lengthy videos of the sad events leaves me perplexed and disquieted. Understanding very little of the spoken language and none the written doesn't help.

Does anyone know what the hierarchy have said following these events?
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: minasoliman on May 20, 2013, 07:54:37 PM
It’s ok.  You can turn an old man who can hardly swing a chair into the criminal of the decade and ignore the public, blatant, “in your face” actions of the homosexuals who want to parade around and make fools of themselves.  It’s ok.  It’s what people do these days.  Cry for the evils of the world and spit at those who want better.  I really enjoy how people focus on actions of those who want no parade and ignore everything else.  A rational thinker would hope you would call out the wrongs on both sides, but perhaps that is asking too much from Christians these days.  I don’t know.  I am looking forward to the prostitutes pride parade where they hand out discount coupons.  Who thinks that is a good idea?  How about Drug Dealer Pride Parades?  Spouse abuser pride day anyone?  And you wonder why people feel the need to go as far as they do in protest.

Yes, but shouldn't a priest be an example to his people?

Have you heard of the Maspero Massacre (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maspero_demonstrations) in Egypt?  26 Copts were killed by bullets and run over by army vehicles in Maspero district of Cairo.  Copts started getting angry and would fight back and try to hurt any soldier involved.  One soldier (Muslim) asked protection from a Coptic priest:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DvUUBg4Xmho

Don't you think that a Coptic priest seeing the mangled and severed bodies around him would be justified to pick up a chair and throw at his tank?

So I ask you, what would you do to a parade of "Drug Dealer Pride" people or "Spousal Abusers"?  Would you pick up a chair and break their cars?

Shame on the Georgian priest!  Shame!
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Tommelomsky on May 20, 2013, 08:25:06 PM
It’s ok.  You can turn an old man who can hardly swing a chair into the criminal of the decade and ignore the public, blatant, “in your face” actions of the homosexuals who want to parade around and make fools of themselves.  It’s ok.  It’s what people do these days.  Cry for the evils of the world and spit at those who want better.  I really enjoy how people focus on actions of those who want no parade and ignore everything else.  A rational thinker would hope you would call out the wrongs on both sides, but perhaps that is asking too much from Christians these days.  I don’t know.  I am looking forward to the prostitutes pride parade where they hand out discount coupons.  Who thinks that is a good idea?  How about Drug Dealer Pride Parades?  Spouse abuser pride day anyone?  And you wonder why people feel the need to go as far as they do in protest.

Yes, but shouldn't a priest be an example to his people?

Have you heard of the Maspero Massacre (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maspero_demonstrations) in Egypt?  26 Copts were killed by bullets and run over by army vehicles in Maspero district of Cairo.  Copts started getting angry and would fight back and try to hurt any soldier involved.  One soldier (Muslim) asked protection from a Coptic priest:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DvUUBg4Xmho

Don't you think that a Coptic priest seeing the mangled and severed bodies around him would be justified to pick up a chair and throw at his tank?

So I ask you, what would you do to a parade of "Drug Dealer Pride" people or "Spousal Abusers"?  Would you pick up a chair and break their cars?

Shame on the Georgian priest!  Shame!

Yes, but remember: He is only a human being. Good or bad choice made.
We should pray for that priest and every priest on this very planet.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Orthodox11 on May 20, 2013, 08:31:29 PM
Shame on the Georgian priest!  Shame!

We don't know if he's a priest. He's wearing monastic attire.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: minasoliman on May 20, 2013, 08:33:27 PM
It’s ok.  You can turn an old man who can hardly swing a chair into the criminal of the decade and ignore the public, blatant, “in your face” actions of the homosexuals who want to parade around and make fools of themselves.  It’s ok.  It’s what people do these days.  Cry for the evils of the world and spit at those who want better.  I really enjoy how people focus on actions of those who want no parade and ignore everything else.  A rational thinker would hope you would call out the wrongs on both sides, but perhaps that is asking too much from Christians these days.  I don’t know.  I am looking forward to the prostitutes pride parade where they hand out discount coupons.  Who thinks that is a good idea?  How about Drug Dealer Pride Parades?  Spouse abuser pride day anyone?  And you wonder why people feel the need to go as far as they do in protest.

Yes, but shouldn't a priest be an example to his people?

Have you heard of the Maspero Massacre (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maspero_demonstrations) in Egypt?  26 Copts were killed by bullets and run over by army vehicles in Maspero district of Cairo.  Copts started getting angry and would fight back and try to hurt any soldier involved.  One soldier (Muslim) asked protection from a Coptic priest:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DvUUBg4Xmho

Don't you think that a Coptic priest seeing the mangled and severed bodies around him would be justified to pick up a chair and throw at his tank?

So I ask you, what would you do to a parade of "Drug Dealer Pride" people or "Spousal Abusers"?  Would you pick up a chair and break their cars?

Shame on the Georgian priest!  Shame!

Yes, but remember: He is only a human being. Good or bad choice made.
We should pray for that priest and every priest on this very planet.

Shame on the Georgian priest!  Shame!

We don't know if he's a priest. He's wearing monastic attire.

If he's a priest, he should be held to a higher standard.  Deposition or excommunication does not mean we won't pray for him.

Do we not remember St. James:  "Not many of you should become teachers, my fellow believers, because you know that we who teach will be judged more strictly." (3:1)

And a monk who's dead to the world, why join the world in violence?
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Tommelomsky on May 20, 2013, 08:40:25 PM
If he was-is a priest, he should indeed have a higher standard. But the way our world has become today, even this..the unthinkable could (and perhaps has) happened.

It is in these times the prayers are so needed. Violence solves nothing (never has and never will).
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: NightOwl on May 20, 2013, 08:41:52 PM
Has the Patriarch issued any statement condemning the violence at the rally?
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: minasoliman on May 20, 2013, 09:53:13 PM
If he was-is a priest, he should indeed have a higher standard. But the way our world has become today, even this..the unthinkable could (and perhaps has) happened.

It is in these times the prayers are so needed. Violence solves nothing (never has and never will).
I'm not saying beat up the priest.  That would be hypocritical.

Yes, the world has and always has been a perverted and violent place to live.  But if a priest in a country where he is the minority can protect and love persecutors from the violence of those persecuted, how much more a priest or a monk in a country where he is part of the majority to protect and love the perverted sinners!

Those who live by the sword shall die by the sword.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Cantor Krishnich on May 20, 2013, 09:55:13 PM
We must understand the culture and politics of Georgia before saying anything. Georgians are pious Orthodox Christians who seriously want to preserve traditional religious ethics in their society with the Church as the center of society. His Holiness is well loved by the faithful including many politicians and he often counsels Georgia acting as spiritual guardian, this is his duty, Eis Polla Eti Despota! Many years to the faithful Georgians who are pushing those who seek to harm the traditional society out of Georgia. Gay-pride parades do not belong in the streets of a religious Orthodox country such as Georgia. Both Homosexuality and Pride are terrible sins and a celebration/parade in honor of such monstrosity would be opposite of Orthodox teachings. The physical fighting between the Orthodox and the Gay-pride supporters was bad and the priest was not supposed to be using a chair as a weapon but the counter-protest was good.  
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: minasoliman on May 20, 2013, 10:08:56 PM
We must understand the culture and politics of Georgia before saying anything. Georgians are pious Orthodox Christians who seriously want to preserve traditional religious ethics in their society with the Church as the center of society. His Holiness is well loved by the faithful including many politicians and he often counsels Georgia acting as spiritual guardian, this is his duty, Eis Polla Eti Despota! Many years to the faithful Georgians who are pushing those who seek to harm the traditional society out of Georgia. Gay-pride parades do not belong in the streets of a religious Orthodox country such as Georgia. Both Homosexuality and Pride are terrible sins and a celebration/parade in honor of such monstrosity would be opposite of Orthodox teachings. The physical fighting between the Orthodox and the Gay-pride supporters was bad and the priest was not supposed to be using a chair as a weapon but the counter-protest was good.   

The idea of the counter-protest is good.  The violence however marred it, and made the protesters look good.  Therefore, I don't see anything good out of it.

It's understandable that Georgians have great love for their country to keep it sanctified, but where is the peace that comes with holiness?
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: NightOwl on May 20, 2013, 10:40:54 PM
We must understand the culture and politics of Georgia before saying anything. Georgians are pious Orthodox Christians who seriously want to preserve traditional religious ethics in their society with the Church as the center of society. His Holiness is well loved by the faithful including many politicians and he often counsels Georgia acting as spiritual guardian, this is his duty, Eis Polla Eti Despota! Many years to the faithful Georgians who are pushing those who seek to harm the traditional society out of Georgia. Gay-pride parades do not belong in the streets of a religious Orthodox country such as Georgia. Both Homosexuality and Pride are terrible sins and a celebration/parade in honor of such monstrosity would be opposite of Orthodox teachings. The physical fighting between the Orthodox and the Gay-pride supporters was bad and the priest was not supposed to be using a chair as a weapon but the counter-protest was good.   

The idea of the counter-protest is good.  The violence however marred it, and made the protesters look good.  Therefore, I don't see anything good out of it.

It's understandable that Georgians have great love for their country to keep it sanctified, but where is the peace that comes with holiness?

Well said, I agree-it's the violence that accompanied the counter-protest which is truly disgraceful and embarrassing for the Orthodox world, rather than the counter-protest itself. Hopefully more Georgian hierarchs will speak out against this and future violence. Maybe they would do well to reflect on the words of the 16th century Patriarch Metrophanes III of Constantinople regarding violence against Jews in Crete:

"Injustice ... regardless to whomever acted upon or performed against, is still injustice. The unjust person is never relieved of the responsibility of these acts under the pretext that the injustice is done against a heterodox and not to a believer. As our Lord Jesus Christ in the Gospels said do not oppress or accuse anyone falsely; do not make any distinction or give room to the believers to injure those of another belief."
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: scamandrius on May 20, 2013, 10:41:11 PM
Good for you!  You know how to use photoshop!

I didn't make it, it's from Georgian media.

Next time include a web citation per oc.net rules of conduct so that you are not mistakenly blamed for its creation.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: orthonorm on May 20, 2013, 10:46:41 PM
Nothing says love like all of the above.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Antonis on May 21, 2013, 01:10:13 AM
Sexual acts between people of the same sex is gravely sinful but nowhere in The New Testament is mob violence supported or condoned. Our Lord's actions and words in the Temple were considered and measured. No comparison can surely be made between the events in the Temple and Tbilisi?

While opposing the ever increasing demands of the Homosexual activist lobby, 'Queer bashing' is repellent. Trying to work out the sequence of events in Tbilisi even after watching lengthy videos of the sad events leaves me perplexed and disquieted. Understanding very little of the spoken language and none the written doesn't help.

Does anyone know what the hierarchy have said following these events?

Patriarch Ilia II comments:

http://www.pravmir.com/georgian-patriarch-calls-on-supporters-opponents-of-gay-movement-to-pray-for-each-other/
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: augustin717 on May 21, 2013, 01:24:49 AM
Nice. He could have said this beforeinstead of calling for a straight parade or whatever it was.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: ativan on May 21, 2013, 02:14:52 AM
Real question is: who loves gay people more? those who support their unchecked behavior and those who promote popularization of it or those who oppose it?

Those who try to rip them to shreds with bare hands propably.
I've supplied important information and asked some questions that need to be answered. Instead of answering you chose to  ridicule me. This is how you argue.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: ativan on May 21, 2013, 02:27:51 AM
There's a lot of misrepresentation of Orthodoxy going on today. Christian first of all is supposed to be a solider of Christ.

Sure, but being a soldier of Christ means entering into spiritual warfare against the devil and the passions. It does not mean using physical violence, especially when there's absolutely no need for it. The sword of the Christian is the Jesus Prayer, as the prayers for tonsuring a monk makes very clear.
Yes, for sure. But being a soldier of Christ also means to physically oppose enemy with every means possible. This is the type of Orthodoxy that has been practiced in Georgia since the time of its conversion. 3 Great saints who founded Iveron Monastery of mount Athos would engage in battle, at the front-line, against enemy while they were monks! This approach has been repeated many times.

In reality, you can't teach us what is correct way of being Orthodox. We've been Orthodox for 2000 years, officially since 334. We have not converted to anything else. If we allowed gay parades in any way, today they would request gay marriage. This has been proved many times already. I do not say this out of pride. I say what I and my countryman feel is true along. Of course, there are minority who does not think so and who think differently but those are fortunately small minority and there opinion in this regard does not count.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: ativan on May 21, 2013, 02:46:16 AM
No, unnecessary violent attacks should not be honoured even when they're perpetrated by the people on the right side of an argument.
It was not unnecessary. Contrary to your statement it was very necessary. We now much better what is necessary for us, believe me. How can you judge from the side when you now nothing about Georgia?

I'm repeating things which apparently was not noticed in my first post here. The attempts to hold those types of parades has been tried several times before and all the time it was stopped by violence. Then I'm asking you: why do you want to persevere and try another such whatever while you know for sure that it will fail? That people will be really angry about it? Why do you want to still hold it while the day prior you've been warned by Church and by people? Who would be responsible if somebody died on so called "anti-homophobia protester" side? I'm not asking rhetorical questions. I really want to know what is your answer to those questions.

More to the point. 3 Georgian soldiers died in Afghanistan and there bodies just arrived the day prior to this date. Country was mourning. They new it but they still dared to come out in the streets to expose their behavior. They wanted to show to the world how they are oppressed and they got what they wanted. Everybody should be happy now and not engaging in pointless philosophical arguments.

If this will make you happy, I will say that though we have all the paraphernalia of 21st century our mentality is still back centuries behind. And I wish we never come out of it. I wish we get closer and closer to our ancestors.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: mike on May 21, 2013, 05:04:07 AM
Well said, I agree-it's the violence that accompanied the counter-protest which is truly disgraceful and embarrassing for the Orthodox world, rather than the counter-protest itself.

The violence in such cases is normal for the sc. Orthodox world.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Santagranddad on May 21, 2013, 05:53:35 AM
Well said, I agree-it's the violence that accompanied the counter-protest which is truly disgraceful and embarrassing for the Orthodox world, rather than the counter-protest itself.

The violence in such cases is normal for the sc. Orthodox world.

I for one for one find your comment at odds with your involvement on an Orthodox Christian forum. In some other environments it might lead to a motion of no confidence. And can you substantiate your assertion?

Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: mike on May 21, 2013, 08:40:22 AM
I for one for one find your comment at odds with your involvement on an Orthodox Christian forum.


Why? It's true. Every gay manifestation in Eastern Europe I've heard ends up being attacked by violent "religious" mob. I would be surprised if for once it wasn't.

Serbia: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Znp8kTGyRx0

Ukraine: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2147385/Horrific-moment-thugs-attack-head-gay-rights-group-Ukraine-forced-cancel-parade-hijacked-neo-Nazi-zealots.html

Russia: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iDOV6qvizmA

Lithuania: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nXwkj1pcexM
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Orthodox11 on May 21, 2013, 08:56:23 AM
Why? It's true. Every gay manifestation in Eastern Europe I've heard ends up being attacked by violent "religious" mob. I would be surprised if for once it wasn't.

Perhaps it's a post-Soviet phenomenon rather than an Orthodox one?
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Romaios on May 21, 2013, 09:02:09 AM
In an appeal to Christians to "peacefully protest" a gay parade in Chișinău the past Sunday, a Moladvian priest writes:

Quote
All that is needed is for 50.000 families (men, women and kids, holding hands) to cross the Ștefan cel Mare Boulevard and greet the bystanders and journalists with "Christ is risen!". That will be enough...

The organizers will need to be extra-careful, because there will be provocations and people who will try to stage altercations and acts of violence. Christians are forbidden to hit or spit anyone! We don't hate homosexuals - only their sin.

Source (http://www.teologie.net/2013/05/15/protest-anti-gay/)

There's a similar appeal from Metropolitan Vladimir (http://mitropolia.md/mitropolia-chisinaului-si-a-intregii-moldove-ia-atitudine-fata-de-organizarea-unei-parade-gay-in-capitala/).
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: mike on May 21, 2013, 09:09:21 AM
Why? It's true. Every gay manifestation in Eastern Europe I've heard ends up being attacked by violent "religious" mob. I would be surprised if for once it wasn't.

Perhaps it's a post-Soviet phenomenon rather than an Orthodox one?

Black Hundreds were also post-Soviet?
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: NightOwl on May 21, 2013, 09:23:36 AM
Well said, I agree-it's the violence that accompanied the counter-protest which is truly disgraceful and embarrassing for the Orthodox world, rather than the counter-protest itself.

The violence in such cases is normal for the sc. Orthodox world.

There are many sins endemic among the Orthodox as with people of other faiths. Something about The Fall, remember? I'm not sure what your point is- I guess you're just trying to be provocative.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: JoeS2 on May 21, 2013, 10:03:58 AM
I for one for one find your comment at odds with your involvement on an Orthodox Christian forum.


Why? It's true. Every gay manifestation in Eastern Europe I've heard ends up being attacked by violent "religious" mob. I would be surprised if for once it wasn't.

Serbia: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Znp8kTGyRx0

Ukraine: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2147385/Horrific-moment-thugs-attack-head-gay-rights-group-Ukraine-forced-cancel-parade-hijacked-neo-Nazi-zealots.html

Russia: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iDOV6qvizmA

Lithuania: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nXwkj1pcexM

Why oh why do the Gays feel the need to rub our heterosexual faces in the mud just to propagate their agenda?  If you want to be gay, OK, if you are gay Ok, but don't push your abomination in my face ,,,,,,,thank you...  Whats wrong in keeping your preference to yourselves?
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Orthodox11 on May 21, 2013, 10:20:49 AM
It's people like these that should be excommunicated.

From what I understand, Mama Basili, who was one of the first to break police lines at the gay rights rally, had already been deposed by the Georgian Church for a previous act of violence and joined one of the Old Calendarist groups upon his release from prison.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: minasoliman on May 21, 2013, 10:50:03 AM
It's people like these that should be excommunicated.

From what I understand, Mama Basili, who was one of the first to break police lines at the gay rights rally, had already been deposed by the Georgian Church for a previous act of violence and joined one of the Old Calendarist groups upon his release from prison.
+1

I praise His Holiness for replying and condemning the violence. It puts some hope that people like Ativan do in fact not represent the Georgian Church.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: augustin717 on May 21, 2013, 10:56:50 AM
In Romania one of the main organizers of the so-called "marches for normality" (also involved with some church run orphanage, IIRC) has been recently outed for his own, say , out of norm preferences. He liked little kiddies.  Certainly not what those that mindlessly spew the phrase "traditional family" have in mind. although, ironically, many "traditional families" were like that.
http://www.evz.ro/detalii/stiri/lider-al-noii-drepte-filma-copii-in-ipostaze-pornografice-1022426.html (http://www.evz.ro/detalii/stiri/lider-al-noii-drepte-filma-copii-in-ipostaze-pornografice-1022426.html)
Where he worked and was taking the pictures:
http://sfstelian.org/ (http://sfstelian.org/)
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: mike on May 21, 2013, 11:09:04 AM
Well said, I agree-it's the violence that accompanied the counter-protest which is truly disgraceful and embarrassing for the Orthodox world, rather than the counter-protest itself.

The violence in such cases is normal for the sc. Orthodox world.

There are many sins endemic among the Orthodox as with people of other faiths. Something about The Fall, remember? I'm not sure what your point is- I guess you're just trying to be provocative.

I'm trying to disprove untrue statements that such things are uncommon some people write here.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: minasoliman on May 21, 2013, 11:42:00 AM
I for one for one find your comment at odds with your involvement on an Orthodox Christian forum.


Why? It's true. Every gay manifestation in Eastern Europe I've heard ends up being attacked by violent "religious" mob. I would be surprised if for once it wasn't.

Serbia: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Znp8kTGyRx0

Ukraine: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2147385/Horrific-moment-thugs-attack-head-gay-rights-group-Ukraine-forced-cancel-parade-hijacked-neo-Nazi-zealots.html

Russia: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iDOV6qvizmA

Lithuania: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nXwkj1pcexM
It's quite telling that these are all places where either Orthodox at the majority or have a strong presence.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Alpo on May 21, 2013, 11:49:49 AM
More to the point. 3 Georgian soldiers died in Afghanistan and there bodies just arrived the day prior to this date. Country was mourning. They new it but they still dared to come out in the streets to expose their behavior. They wanted to show to the world how they are oppressed and they got what they wanted. Everybody should be happy now and not engaging in pointless philosophical arguments.

Wait, what? Using freedom of expression is a legitimate reason for violence? ???
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Balthasar on May 21, 2013, 11:55:51 AM
We must understand the culture and politics of Georgia before saying anything. Georgians are pious Orthodox Christians who seriously want to preserve traditional religious ethics in their society with the Church as the center of society. His Holiness is well loved by the faithful including many politicians and he often counsels Georgia acting as spiritual guardian, this is his duty, Eis Polla Eti Despota! Many years to the faithful Georgians who are pushing those who seek to harm the traditional society out of Georgia. Gay-pride parades do not belong in the streets of a religious Orthodox country such as Georgia. Both Homosexuality and Pride are terrible sins and a celebration/parade in honor of such monstrosity would be opposite of Orthodox teachings. The physical fighting between the Orthodox and the Gay-pride supporters was bad and the priest was not supposed to be using a chair as a weapon but the counter-protest was good.  

Absolutely right!

I know there are some non-Christians on this forum, but, still, It is depressing to see "Christians" judging their own brothers repeatedly. In terms of real "violence", it's peanuts what our Georgian brothers demonstrated in the video. They have not killed nobody. It's easy, and at times luckewarmish, to sit behind a computer and comment with ignorance. I wonder how would folks react when some of these sodomite criminals live next to them burning them with microwave radiation, or sending them HIV-infected things to them. Yes! This is terrible to say, but it's this what's happening to many Christian leaders, Christians in many parts of the developed world. Google it! Until recently these sodomite groups were classified as dangerous criminal groups with the police forces of Austria, Switzerland and Germany.  :police:
There are two groups of people at the moment who have been used by the evils of this world to destroy Christianity: that are Islmists and Sodomites! If you care and love, as you say, these folks, please tell them to stop being Muslims or Gays, tell them to halt their anti-Christian agenda, tell them to undergo some kind of spiritual healing, tell them, otherwise, they are heading to hell.

Bless the tough Georgians, and please never judge your own brothers and sisters!

Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: augustin717 on May 21, 2013, 12:00:50 PM
Quote
I wonder how would folks react when some of these sodomite criminals live next to them burning them with microwave radiation]I wonder how would folks react when some of these sodomite criminals live next to them burning them with microwave radiation
that's what they have been doing to you?
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Santagranddad on May 21, 2013, 12:01:31 PM
Well said, I agree-it's the violence that accompanied the counter-protest which is truly disgraceful and embarrassing for the Orthodox world, rather than the counter-protest itself.

The violence in such cases is normal for the sc. Orthodox world.

There are many sins endemic among the Orthodox as with people of other faiths. Something about The Fall, remember? I'm not sure what your point is- I guess you're just trying to be provocative.

I'm trying to disprove untrue statements that such things are uncommon some people write here.

Pardon? I don't understand your point?
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: mike on May 21, 2013, 12:02:00 PM
I wonder how would folks react when some of these sodomite criminals live next to them burning them with microwave radiation, or sending them HIV-infected things to them.

LOL

Bless the tough Georgians, and please never judge your own brothers and sisters!

Like you judged homosexuals?
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Santagranddad on May 21, 2013, 12:05:51 PM
This thread reminds now of 'One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest'. But infinitely less amusing.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: NightOwl on May 21, 2013, 12:12:29 PM
Well said, I agree-it's the violence that accompanied the counter-protest which is truly disgraceful and embarrassing for the Orthodox world, rather than the counter-protest itself.

The violence in such cases is normal for the sc. Orthodox world.

There are many sins endemic among the Orthodox as with people of other faiths. Something about The Fall, remember? I'm not sure what your point is- I guess you're just trying to be provocative.

I'm trying to disprove untrue statements that such things are uncommon some people write here.

OK... who's arguing it's uncommon?
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: ialmisry on May 21, 2013, 12:15:24 PM
I for one for one find your comment at odds with your involvement on an Orthodox Christian forum.


Why? It's true. Every gay manifestation in Eastern Europe I've heard ends up being attacked by violent "religious" mob. I would be surprised if for once it wasn't.

Serbia: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Znp8kTGyRx0

Ukraine: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2147385/Horrific-moment-thugs-attack-head-gay-rights-group-Ukraine-forced-cancel-parade-hijacked-neo-Nazi-zealots.html

Russia: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iDOV6qvizmA

Lithuania: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nXwkj1pcexM
It's quite telling that these are all places where either Orthodox at the majority or have a strong presence.
telling what exactly?
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: augustin717 on May 21, 2013, 12:17:03 PM
This thread reminds now of 'One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest'. But infinitely less amusing.
we get it your victorian sensibiities have been gravely offended. someone fetch the salts.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: ialmisry on May 21, 2013, 12:26:19 PM
More to the point. 3 Georgian soldiers died in Afghanistan and there bodies just arrived the day prior to this date. Country was mourning. They new it but they still dared to come out in the streets to expose their behavior. They wanted to show to the world how they are oppressed and they got what they wanted. Everybody should be happy now and not engaging in pointless philosophical arguments.

Wait, what? Using freedom of expression is a legitimate reason for violence? ???
It is called "fighting words."
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: TheTrisagion on May 21, 2013, 12:29:47 PM
This thread reminds now of 'One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest'. But infinitely less amusing.
we get it your victorian sensibiities have been gravely offended. someone fetch the salts.

That comment doesn't make any sense.  Do you know what One Flew OVer the Cuckoo's Nest is about?  I'll give you a hint. Its not about "victorian sensibilities".
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: augustin717 on May 21, 2013, 12:36:25 PM
This thread reminds now of 'One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest'. But infinitely less amusing.
we get it your victorian sensibiities have been gravely offended. someone fetch the salts.

That comment doesn't make any sense.  Do you know what One Flew OVer the Cuckoo's Nest is about?  I'll give you a hint. Its not about "victorian sensibilities".
the fact the both of you are particularly shocked that some people aren't shocked by what you call "public semi-nudity".
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: TheTrisagion on May 21, 2013, 12:44:19 PM
This thread reminds now of 'One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest'. But infinitely less amusing.
we get it your victorian sensibiities have been gravely offended. someone fetch the salts.

That comment doesn't make any sense.  Do you know what One Flew OVer the Cuckoo's Nest is about?  I'll give you a hint. Its not about "victorian sensibilities".
the fact the both of you are particularly shocked that some people aren't shocked by what you call "public semi-nudity".

I'm not shocked by it at all. Just because I don't prefer to see public semi or full nudity does not mean I'm victorian or shocked by it.  I also don't like airplanes flying over my house because they are noisy.  Am I anti-technologist as well?

One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest, though, refers to the novel about an insane asylum.  The point he was trying to make is that just about everyone in this threat is saying ridiculous statement that are completely without logic and insane.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Santagranddad on May 21, 2013, 01:26:12 PM
This thread reminds now of 'One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest'. But infinitely less amusing.
we get it your victorian sensibiities have been gravely offended. someone fetch the salts.

Sir, I doubt you even know anything about the Victorians, much less their sensibilities. And the 'we' in your response - is this the Royal we or have I missed something.

This thread is full of partisan views, immoderately expressed viewpoints, the Church's teaching on modesty ridiculed even blasphemy. Truly it feels somewhat as if the lunatics have taken over and the moderators are locked in the nurses station.

It this chaotic and increasingly frantic environment which reminds me of the film.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Orthodox11 on May 21, 2013, 02:07:35 PM
It's people like these that should be excommunicated.

From what I understand, Mama Basili, who was one of the first to break police lines at the gay rights rally, had already been deposed by the Georgian Church for a previous act of violence and joined one of the Old Calendarist groups upon his release from prison.
+1

I praise His Holiness for replying and condemning the violence. It puts some hope that people like Ativan do in fact not represent the Georgian Church.

I just checked the website of the Old Calendar group in question and he's no longer listed among their clergy in Georgia, so I don't know what his status was as of Friday.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Orthodox11 on May 21, 2013, 02:53:23 PM
Basili Mkalavishvili (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basili_Mkalavishvili)


About Friday's protest:
Quote
According to Georgia’s Inter Press News service, the anti-gay protesters carried icons and posters proclaiming: “Homosexuals, away from Georgia.” They also brought eggs and stinging nettles to the protest, threatening to lash anyone who “deserved” such treatment.
Basili Mkalavishvili, an outspoken defrocked Georgian Orthodox priest who was sentenced to six years in 2005 for a series of attacks against minority religious edifices, pledged to “start a revolution of nettles to protect orthodox Christendom,” describing the plant as a symbol of Orthodox Christendom directed against homosexuals.
“There has been a rose and broom revolution; we are starting the revolution of nettles to protect orthodox Christians. We, as Orthodox Christians, won’t let them [homosexuals] walk down the holy streets,” Inter Press News quoted Mkalavishvili as saying.
http://en.ria.ru/world/20130517/181207800.html
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: minasoliman on May 21, 2013, 05:52:45 PM
I for one for one find your comment at odds with your involvement on an Orthodox Christian forum.


Why? It's true. Every gay manifestation in Eastern Europe I've heard ends up being attacked by violent "religious" mob. I would be surprised if for once it wasn't.

Serbia: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Znp8kTGyRx0

Ukraine: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2147385/Horrific-moment-thugs-attack-head-gay-rights-group-Ukraine-forced-cancel-parade-hijacked-neo-Nazi-zealots.html

Russia: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iDOV6qvizmA

Lithuania: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nXwkj1pcexM
It's quite telling that these are all places where either Orthodox at the majority or have a strong presence.
telling what exactly?
That usually Christians act like real charitable Christians when they're a minority.  When they're a majority, there's a diversity of them, including apathetic nominal Christians and Christians who advocate violence, as shown here.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: minasoliman on May 21, 2013, 05:55:15 PM
It's people like these that should be excommunicated.

From what I understand, Mama Basili, who was one of the first to break police lines at the gay rights rally, had already been deposed by the Georgian Church for a previous act of violence and joined one of the Old Calendarist groups upon his release from prison.
+1

I praise His Holiness for replying and condemning the violence. It puts some hope that people like Ativan do in fact not represent the Georgian Church.

I just checked the website of the Old Calendar group in question and he's no longer listed among their clergy in Georgia, so I don't know what his status was as of Friday.
If the implication is that he's cut off from the Old Calendar group, good for them too!  This shows that strict "fundamentalist" Christians are peaceful by nature, not violent.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Santagranddad on May 21, 2013, 06:13:39 PM
Amen
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: orthonorm on May 21, 2013, 07:19:27 PM
I for one for one find your comment at odds with your involvement on an Orthodox Christian forum.


Why? It's true. Every gay manifestation in Eastern Europe I've heard ends up being attacked by violent "religious" mob. I would be surprised if for once it wasn't.

Serbia: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Znp8kTGyRx0

Ukraine: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2147385/Horrific-moment-thugs-attack-head-gay-rights-group-Ukraine-forced-cancel-parade-hijacked-neo-Nazi-zealots.html

Russia: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iDOV6qvizmA

Lithuania: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nXwkj1pcexM
It's quite telling that these are all places where either Orthodox at the majority or have a strong presence.
telling what exactly?
That usually Christians act like real charitable Christians when they're a minority.  When they're a majority, there's a diversity of them, including apathetic nominal Christians and Christians who advocate violence, as shown here.

Wow. Someone other than in augustin making sense in the last two pages.

Some real disgusting comments around here.

Thanks mina.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Shiny on May 21, 2013, 07:24:25 PM
I for one for one find your comment at odds with your involvement on an Orthodox Christian forum.


Why? It's true. Every gay manifestation in Eastern Europe I've heard ends up being attacked by violent "religious" mob. I would be surprised if for once it wasn't.

Serbia: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Znp8kTGyRx0

Ukraine: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2147385/Horrific-moment-thugs-attack-head-gay-rights-group-Ukraine-forced-cancel-parade-hijacked-neo-Nazi-zealots.html

Russia: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iDOV6qvizmA

Lithuania: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nXwkj1pcexM
It's quite telling that these are all places where either Orthodox at the majority or have a strong presence.
telling what exactly?
That usually Christians act like real charitable Christians when they're a minority.  When they're a majority, there's a diversity of them, including apathetic nominal Christians and Christians who advocate violence, as shown here.

Wow. Someone other than in augustin making sense in the last two pages.

Some real disgusting comments around here.

Thanks mina.
I'm waiting for the Bible verses to defend such actions
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: ativan on May 22, 2013, 03:05:44 AM
We must understand the culture and politics of Georgia before saying anything. Georgians are pious Orthodox Christians who seriously want to preserve traditional religious ethics in their society with the Church as the center of society. His Holiness is well loved by the faithful including many politicians and he often counsels Georgia acting as spiritual guardian, this is his duty, Eis Polla Eti Despota! Many years to the faithful Georgians who are pushing those who seek to harm the traditional society out of Georgia. Gay-pride parades do not belong in the streets of a religious Orthodox country such as Georgia. Both Homosexuality and Pride are terrible sins and a celebration/parade in honor of such monstrosity would be opposite of Orthodox teachings. The physical fighting between the Orthodox and the Gay-pride supporters was bad and the priest was not supposed to be using a chair as a weapon but the counter-protest was good.

We must understand the culture and politics of Georgia before saying anything. Georgians are pious Orthodox Christians who seriously want to preserve traditional religious ethics in their society with the Church as the center of society. His Holiness is well loved by the faithful including many politicians and he often counsels Georgia acting as spiritual guardian, this is his duty, Eis Polla Eti Despota! Many years to the faithful Georgians who are pushing those who seek to harm the traditional society out of Georgia. Gay-pride parades do not belong in the streets of a religious Orthodox country such as Georgia. Both Homosexuality and Pride are terrible sins and a celebration/parade in honor of such monstrosity would be opposite of Orthodox teachings. The physical fighting between the Orthodox and the Gay-pride supporters was bad and the priest was not supposed to be using a chair as a weapon but the counter-protest was good.   
Absolutely right!

I know there are some non-Christians on this forum, but, still, It is depressing to see "Christians" judging their own brothers repeatedly. In terms of real "violence", it's peanuts what our Georgian brothers demonstrated in the video. They have not killed nobody. It's easy, and at times luckewarmish, to sit behind a computer and comment with ignorance. I wonder how would folks react when some of these sodomite criminals live next to them burning them with microwave radiation, or sending them HIV-infected things to them. Yes! This is terrible to say, but it's this what's happening to many Christian leaders, Christians in many parts of the developed world. Google it! Until recently these sodomite groups were classified as dangerous criminal groups with the police forces of Austria, Switzerland and Germany.  :police:
There are two groups of people at the moment who have been used by the evils of this world to destroy Christianity: that are Islmists and Sodomites! If you care and love, as you say, these folks, please tell them to stop being Muslims or Gays, tell them to halt their anti-Christian agenda, tell them to undergo some kind of spiritual healing, tell them, otherwise, they are heading to hell.

Bless the tough Georgians, and please never judge your own brothers and sisters!

Thank you brothers in Christ

Unfortunately this age has so much distorted Orthodoxy that normal is taken as abnormal and the other way round. People can't even think in terms of the past, in terms of their ancestors. They call us middle age beasts just because we remember past and stick to our ancestor's teaching and moral. Not that I wary about us leaving in cage. It is those who have lost touch with the past and with their ancestors that are really pitiful.

Our saintly king Vakhtang Gorgasali when dying said these words: "be strong in your faith and look forward to die for the Christ so that you can find permanent glory". We remember up to now his words.

17 th century traveler Don Pietro Avitabile traveled through Georgia. It was the time when Persian Shah Abbas destroyed cities and leveled houses and churches to the ground. The robbed Georgia and everything in here. People had no food. They were hungry and drained of power. Clergy had no Eucharist clothes or objects. In spite of these people did not fall in any despair and still stayed pridefully. Don Pietro reports what they were saying: "Even if Christ's faith will be rooted out of the whole world we will still retain pure faith of Christ".

And they want to inject this garbage in this country with this much tradition. That will not happen and even if violence is necessary we should not stop. This "violence" was just to show those people that they can do whatever they want to do in their house (and everybody who protested against immorality explicitly stated this and whoever know Georgian will hear it) but do not bring this in the streets. We will not allow them to spoil future Generation. Future Generation is jewel for our Country. I don't wish any country in the world whatever I don't wish my country. God bless all faithful.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: mike on May 22, 2013, 07:38:20 AM
OK... who's arguing it's uncommon?

You are mistaken, once again.

This is NOT how all Orthodox protest against sin.

Why are you always so adamant to plop everyone in to one basket?

You are mistaken, once again.

This is NOT how all Orthodox protest against sin.

Same in Serbia, Ukraine, Russia etc.

Really?  I hadn't heard about it.

:(Watched the news on RT today and witnessed the violent and unedifying blockading of a so-called 'Gay Pride' parade in Tbilisi, Georgia. The news strip running below the news pictures had 'Christians block Gay Pride march'. The newsreader spoke of protestors lead by Orthodox Christian priests. What I saw extremely violent attacks on vehicles presumably trying to get the Pride marchers away in a minibus with broken windows and a screaming mob trying to knock seven barrels of .... out of whatever they could lay their fists on.

I have seen 'Gay Pride' marches before and found the over the top behaviour and outfits difficult to stomach, but this protest would best described as deeply shameful and mob violence rather than a protest by Christians.

Church Militant didn't even begin to describe it.

Okay, show me where the angry, violent mob is. Where is the Catholicos Patriarch urging people to beat up gays? For God's sake...

This is a single isolated event.  If Orthodox Christians the world over were attacking people, it would be different, but they are not.

I understand some of this posts are naive, but IMHO some are purposely misleading.

Our saintly king Vakhtang Gorgasali when dying said these words: "be strong in your faith and look forward to die for the Christ so that you can find permanent glory". We remember up to now his words.

It looks like you ignore his words and try to make others die for Christ, not yourselves.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: ativan on May 22, 2013, 10:15:40 AM
Our saintly king Vakhtang Gorgasali when dying said these words: "be strong in your faith and look forward to die for the Christ so that you can find permanent glory". We remember up to now his words.

It looks like you ignore his words and try to make others die for Christ, not yourselves.
It looks like for you truth is as much important as for me learning magic, which I care nothing about.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: TheTrisagion on May 22, 2013, 10:19:18 AM
ativan, do you live in Georgia?  I'm curious as to hearing more about your thoughts regarding what went on in the protest.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Punch on May 22, 2013, 10:25:40 AM
Our saintly king Vakhtang Gorgasali when dying said these words: "be strong in your faith and look forward to die for the Christ so that you can find permanent glory". We remember up to now his words.

It looks like you ignore his words and try to make others die for Christ, not yourselves.
It looks like for you truth is as much important as for me learning magic, which I care nothing about.

LOL.  I am really starting to like you.  A lot.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: ativan on May 22, 2013, 10:59:44 AM
ativan, do you live in Georgia?  I'm curious as to hearing more about your thoughts regarding what went on in the protest.
Currently I live in US and will be going back to Georgia soon. But I do know in details what happened. Some preliminaries: 1) This gay pride thing had been tried in Georgia several times before which failed each time. It turned into another mildly violent clash last year. They have tried to hold this also in Batumi City 2-3 years back and again failed. Many people came out in the streets. 2) Country was mourning three dead Georgian soldiers who died in Afghanistan and these people were warned not to chose this time. 3) Besides, as I know they've been also told if they wanted to hold such a thing to choose another place since that particular place is also important for Georgians. In April 9 of 1989 (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/April_9_tragedy) 20 Georgians died out of Russian's hand for freedom. Conducting such a dirty show in a sacred spot is very painful for Georgians. 4) Catholicos Patriarch Ilia II has warned them that it was not a good idea and would lead to opposition. 5) There's was a gathering the day prior at that particular area and people clearly expressed that such a thing should not be hold.

In short if they (organizer's of gay parade) really cared about democracy and if they really were rational beings they would've aborted the whole thing.

As Georgian's position against gay people is concerned it is such: they've lived in our country before these incidents and nobody was hurt because they were gay. We don't think we are any batter then them. Although we recognize that it is abominable sin we don't judge them. They can do whatever they want to do in their own homes (and this was clearly stated by many protesters), though as a human I don't wish them to be sunk in such a sin. Violence was not an effect of our hate against them (which we don't have to start with) but an act to curtail the spread of disease in the future generation, that's it. I totally support such a thing because future generation matters for me. I have 2 children on my own. If I don't wish anything like these to them I don't wish it to any child in the world and God knows it.

I should admit though that our Church is not perfect either and we too have totally unholy priests some of whom are even hidden gays themselves. Our church is not perfect; Our clergy may exhibit aggression or whatever, they are also humans. I definitely will not approve Priest's aggression (but they should be involved in such matters) against gays. Though as I've already mentioned I totally approve such a "prophylactic" on people's side. To me it also seems that this was "controlled" violence. If we really hated gays there would've been many dead bodies before and after. In reality nobody got hurt seriously. There were minor injuries only.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: mike on May 22, 2013, 11:25:19 AM
In short if they (organizer's of gay parade) really cared about democracy and if they really were rational beings they would've aborted the whole thing.

Democracy means also respecting minority rights.

Quote
I totally support such a thing because future generation matters for me. I have 2 children on my own. If I don't wish anything like these to them I don't wish it to any child in the world and God knows it.

How would that parade harm your children?

Quote
To me it also seems that this was "controlled" violence. If we really hated gays there would've been many dead bodies before and after. In reality nobody got hurt seriously. There were minor injuries only.

Thanks to police. Rioters would tear them apart.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: ativan on May 22, 2013, 11:43:12 AM
In short if they (organizer's of gay parade) really cared about democracy and if they really were rational beings they would've aborted the whole thing.

Democracy means also respecting minority rights.
Democracy means also respecting majority rights. Majority decided that such a thing would be unhealthy and decided to stop it. This is true democracy and not pseudo-democracy: minority and majority both exercised their rights in full not unlike in many places where police tries to keep majority off stopping minorities shameful attempts.

Quote
Quote
I totally support such a thing because future generation matters for me. I have 2 children on my own. If I don't wish anything like these to them I don't wish it to any child in the world and God knows it.

How would that parade harm your children?
This is why I said truth is not what you seek for. If it was then the answer would have been clear. If you can't see how it protects children I don't think any explanation would help you to understand the problem.

Quote
Quote
To me it also seems that this was "controlled" violence. If we really hated gays there would've been many dead bodies before and after. In reality nobody got hurt seriously. There were minor injuries only.

Thanks to police. Rioters would tear them apart.
That is untrue again. It was mostly clergy and people that gays did not get injured seriously. Police did try to protect gays but in many cases they in fact let the people against gay and this is explicit on many videos.

In spite of your attempts to make us look like animals and cannibals we are humans. This may hurt you but it's true. Georgians are humans.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: podkarpatska on May 22, 2013, 11:51:32 AM
Democracy is complicated and messy. Tocqueville said it best in his early 19th century essay on the tyranny of the majority in his masterwork, " Democracy in America." It's worth the read. 

http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/news/2216858/posts
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: vamrat on May 22, 2013, 12:14:35 PM
In short if they (organizer's of gay parade) really cared about democracy and if they really were rational beings they would've aborted the whole thing.

Democracy means also respecting minority rights.


What are the laws in Georgia regarding assembly?  In the US we have freedom of assembly but even this has restrictions.  If freedom of assembly is not guaranteed by the Georgian constitution then whichever bean counter approved of this despite repeated complaints from the majority is at fault for this.


Besides, Democracy is all about the rights of the majority.  The minorities be damned.  This is why so many historical authors spoke poorly of it as a system.  Now, some specific democracies guarantee the rights of the minorities, but this is not inherent in the system.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: ialmisry on May 22, 2013, 12:19:12 PM
In short if they (organizer's of gay parade) really cared about democracy and if they really were rational beings they would've aborted the whole thing.

Democracy means also respecting minority rights.


What are the laws in Georgia regarding assembly?  In the US we have freedom of assembly but even this has restrictions.  If freedom of assembly is not guaranteed by the Georgian constitution then whichever bean counter approved of this despite repeated complaints from the majority is at fault for this.


Besides, Democracy is all about the rights of the majority.  The minorities be damned.  This is why so many historical authors spoke poorly of it as a system.  Now, some specific democracies guarantee the rights of the minorities, but this is not inherent in the system.

in the cradle of democracy, Athens, only a small minority had any rights to respect.

Georgia needs only to look to San Francisco to see where this leads.  The majority has a right to make sure that never happens.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: ialmisry on May 22, 2013, 12:34:22 PM
I for one for one find your comment at odds with your involvement on an Orthodox Christian forum.


Why? It's true. Every gay manifestation in Eastern Europe I've heard ends up being attacked by violent "religious" mob. I would be surprised if for once it wasn't.

Serbia: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Znp8kTGyRx0

Ukraine: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2147385/Horrific-moment-thugs-attack-head-gay-rights-group-Ukraine-forced-cancel-parade-hijacked-neo-Nazi-zealots.html

Russia: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iDOV6qvizmA

Lithuania: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nXwkj1pcexM
It's quite telling that these are all places where either Orthodox at the majority or have a strong presence.
telling what exactly?
That usually Christians act like real charitable Christians when they're a minority.  When they're a majority, there's a diversity of them, including apathetic nominal Christians and Christians who advocate violence, as shown here.
Not exactly.  I know plenty of the history of the Christians while a minority in the Middle East that the diversity you speak of exists.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: ialmisry on May 22, 2013, 12:40:26 PM
In short if they (organizer's of gay parade) really cared about democracy and if they really were rational beings they would've aborted the whole thing.

Democracy means also respecting minority rights.

Quote
I totally support such a thing because future generation matters for me. I have 2 children on my own. If I don't wish anything like these to them I don't wish it to any child in the world and God knows it.

How would that parade harm your children?
(http://www.ushmm.org/propaganda/assets/images/500x/hitler-nazi-parade.jpg)
(http://www.saak.nl/battlefield%20tour/2008%20berlin/fuhrerbunker/fuhrerbunker%20(17).jpg)
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Iconodule on May 22, 2013, 12:49:04 PM
In short if they (organizer's of gay parade) really cared about democracy and if they really were rational beings they would've aborted the whole thing.

Democracy means also respecting minority rights.

Quote
I totally support such a thing because future generation matters for me. I have 2 children on my own. If I don't wish anything like these to them I don't wish it to any child in the world and God knows it.

How would that parade harm your children?
(http://www.ushmm.org/propaganda/assets/images/500x/hitler-nazi-parade.jpg)
(http://www.saak.nl/battlefield%20tour/2008%20berlin/fuhrerbunker/fuhrerbunker%20(17).jpg)

Keepin' it classy as always.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: augustin717 on May 22, 2013, 12:56:22 PM
In short if they (organizer's of gay parade) really cared about democracy and if they really were rational beings they would've aborted the whole thing.

Democracy means also respecting minority rights.


What are the laws in Georgia regarding assembly?  In the US we have freedom of assembly but even this has restrictions.  If freedom of assembly is not guaranteed by the Georgian constitution then whichever bean counter approved of this despite repeated complaints from the majority is at fault for this.


Besides, Democracy is all about the rights of the majority.  The minorities be damned.  This is why so many historical authors spoke poorly of it as a system.  Now, some specific democracies guarantee the rights of the minorities, but this is not inherent in the system.

in the cradle of democracy, Athens, only a small minority had any rights to respect.

Georgia needs only to look to San Francisco to see where this leads.  The majority has a right to make sure that never happens.
lulz
you mean make sure it doesn't get as thriving as SF?
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: podkarpatska on May 22, 2013, 12:57:15 PM
When all else fails, bring on the Nazis. Yuck.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Punch on May 22, 2013, 01:03:15 PM
When all else fails, bring on the Nazis. Yuck.

I'm sorry, but they did have some of the best parades.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: podkarpatska on May 22, 2013, 01:06:57 PM
When all else fails, bring on the Nazis. Yuck.

I'm sorry, but they did have some of the best parades.

You are a bad..that made me laugh!  ;)
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: TheTrisagion on May 22, 2013, 01:09:22 PM
Reductio ad Hitlerum  ::)
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: vamrat on May 22, 2013, 01:46:26 PM
When all else fails, bring on the Nazis. Yuck.

I'm sorry, but they did have some of the best parades.

IDK.  The modern Russians are giving them a run for their money.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Punch on May 22, 2013, 01:47:17 PM
When all else fails, bring on the Nazis. Yuck.

I'm sorry, but they did have some of the best parades.

IDK.  The modern Russians are giving them a run for their money.

True.  The last couple of ones in Moscow were quite good.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: minasoliman on May 22, 2013, 05:00:42 PM
I for one for one find your comment at odds with your involvement on an Orthodox Christian forum.


Why? It's true. Every gay manifestation in Eastern Europe I've heard ends up being attacked by violent "religious" mob. I would be surprised if for once it wasn't.

Serbia: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Znp8kTGyRx0

Ukraine: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2147385/Horrific-moment-thugs-attack-head-gay-rights-group-Ukraine-forced-cancel-parade-hijacked-neo-Nazi-zealots.html

Russia: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iDOV6qvizmA

Lithuania: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nXwkj1pcexM
It's quite telling that these are all places where either Orthodox at the majority or have a strong presence.
telling what exactly?
That usually Christians act like real charitable Christians when they're a minority.  When they're a majority, there's a diversity of them, including apathetic nominal Christians and Christians who advocate violence, as shown here.
Not exactly.  I know plenty of the history of the Christians while a minority in the Middle East that the diversity you speak of exists.
Thats why I said "usually"
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: podkarpatska on May 22, 2013, 05:12:58 PM
When all else fails, bring on the Nazis. Yuck.

I'm sorry, but they did have some of the best parades.

IDK.  The modern Russians are giving them a run for their money.

True.  The last couple of ones in Moscow were quite good.

You have to admit though that North Korea really goes over the top on such things. Sort of the Super Bowl halftime on crack and meth.... Sort of a totalitarian Vegas.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Punch on May 22, 2013, 05:21:34 PM
You have to admit though that North Korea really goes over the top on such things. Sort of the Super Bowl halftime on crack and meth.... Sort of a totalitarian Vegas.

Have you watched their women soldiers goosestep?  Wow!  It causes an emotion in me that I don't think is good for me to have, so I switch to something else.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: podkarpatska on May 22, 2013, 05:27:11 PM
You have to admit though that North Korea really goes over the top on such things. Sort of the Super Bowl halftime on crack and meth.... Sort of a totalitarian Vegas.

Have you watched their women soldiers goosestep?  Wow!  It causes an emotion in me that I don't think is good for me to have, so I switch to something else.

Like I said, an alternate universe Vegas.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: ialmisry on May 22, 2013, 06:44:01 PM
In short if they (organizer's of gay parade) really cared about democracy and if they really were rational beings they would've aborted the whole thing.

Democracy means also respecting minority rights.


What are the laws in Georgia regarding assembly?  In the US we have freedom of assembly but even this has restrictions.  If freedom of assembly is not guaranteed by the Georgian constitution then whichever bean counter approved of this despite repeated complaints from the majority is at fault for this.


Besides, Democracy is all about the rights of the majority.  The minorities be damned.  This is why so many historical authors spoke poorly of it as a system.  Now, some specific democracies guarantee the rights of the minorities, but this is not inherent in the system.

in the cradle of democracy, Athens, only a small minority had any rights to respect.

Georgia needs only to look to San Francisco to see where this leads.  The majority has a right to make sure that never happens.
lulz
you mean make sure it doesn't get as thriving as SF?
was miring down a cesspool when I saw it four years ago.  Around the same time Michael Savage saw it:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BJmmMgnIQaw
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JKWviKFiPQQ
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FE8Qo3l9TZo

You need a future generation for having a future
Quote
San Francisco becoming a child-free zone as youth population declines

Despite efforts to stem the tide of family flight, the population of children in San Francisco continues to ebb.

Families that remain in The City are bucking the trend that has plagued San Francisco for years as the number of children — defined as people up to 17 years old — has dropped from 181,532 in 1960 to 107,524 today, according to the latest U.S. Census Bureau figures. The 2000 census counted 112,802 youths.

The decrease is disappointing news for city officials, who have attempted to counter the family-flight trend by creating more affordable housing, improving schools and cutting costs, such as a college savings account for kindergarten enrollees.   
http://www.sfexaminer.com/local/2011/03/san-francisco-becoming-child-free-zone-youth-population-declines#ixzz2U44RXzdv

Quote
The San Francisco and San Jose metro regions, which added more than 1.1 million new jobs from 1992-2000, produced fewer than 70,000 jobs between 2000 and 2008—a dropoff of 95%.
http://www.discoverthenetworks.org/viewSubCategory.asp?id=1678
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: ialmisry on May 22, 2013, 06:45:21 PM
In short if they (organizer's of gay parade) really cared about democracy and if they really were rational beings they would've aborted the whole thing.

Democracy means also respecting minority rights.

Quote
I totally support such a thing because future generation matters for me. I have 2 children on my own. If I don't wish anything like these to them I don't wish it to any child in the world and God knows it.

How would that parade harm your children?
(http://www.ushmm.org/propaganda/assets/images/500x/hitler-nazi-parade.jpg)
(http://www.saak.nl/battlefield%20tour/2008%20berlin/fuhrerbunker/fuhrerbunker%20(17).jpg)

Keepin' it classy as always.
better than staying ignorant.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: ialmisry on May 22, 2013, 06:53:07 PM
When all else fails, bring on the Nazis. Yuck.
(http://media.platypus1917.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/05/96106-050-B707D2ED-470x260.jpg)
(http://cache.daylife.com/imageserve/02Ft0gDa8Kbik/439x.jpg)
(http://i.telegraph.co.uk/multimedia/archive/01492/mao1938_1492424i.jpg)
(http://www.kingsacademy.com/mhodges/03_The-World-since-1900/11_The-Bewildering-60s/pictures/girls-studying-Mao's-Red-Book.jpg)
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Santagranddad on May 22, 2013, 07:00:23 PM
When all else fails, bring on the Nazis. Yuck.
(http://media.platypus1917.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/05/96106-050-B707D2ED-470x260.jpg)
(http://cache.daylife.com/imageserve/02Ft0gDa8Kbik/439x.jpg)
(http://i.telegraph.co.uk/multimedia/archive/01492/mao1938_1492424i.jpg)
(http://www.kingsacademy.com/mhodges/03_The-World-since-1900/11_The-Bewildering-60s/pictures/girls-studying-Mao's-Red-Book.jpg)

Yuck, murdering Red fascists - who actually killed more people than the Axis powers.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: TheTrisagion on May 22, 2013, 07:03:55 PM
Reductio ad dictatorum  ::)
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Shanghaiski on May 22, 2013, 07:23:38 PM
Why? It's true. Every gay manifestation in Eastern Europe I've heard ends up being attacked by violent "religious" mob. I would be surprised if for once it wasn't.

Perhaps it's a post-Soviet phenomenon rather than an Orthodox one?

That might be. Mykonos in Greece was, according to the Lonely Planet guide, the biggest gay tourist destination in Europe until it was supplanted by some place in Spain.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Shanghaiski on May 22, 2013, 07:26:07 PM
I for one for one find your comment at odds with your involvement on an Orthodox Christian forum.


Why? It's true. Every gay manifestation in Eastern Europe I've heard ends up being attacked by violent "religious" mob. I would be surprised if for once it wasn't.

Serbia: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Znp8kTGyRx0

Ukraine: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2147385/Horrific-moment-thugs-attack-head-gay-rights-group-Ukraine-forced-cancel-parade-hijacked-neo-Nazi-zealots.html

Russia: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iDOV6qvizmA

Lithuania: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nXwkj1pcexM

Why oh why do the Gays feel the need to rub our heterosexual faces in the mud just to propagate their agenda?  If you want to be gay, OK, if you are gay Ok, but don't push your abomination in my face ,,,,,,,thank you...  Whats wrong in keeping your preference to yourselves?

Because, since they cannot acknowledge a problem with themselves, the problem therefore must lie with society. Therefore, the society must be change. Then, supposedly, they will stop killing themselves .
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Shanghaiski on May 22, 2013, 07:39:05 PM
When all else fails, bring on the Nazis. Yuck.

I'm sorry, but they did have some of the best parades.

IDK.  The modern Russians are giving them a run for their money.

True.  The last couple of ones in Moscow were quite good.

You have to admit though that North Korea really goes over the top on such things. Sort of the Super Bowl halftime on crack and meth.... Sort of a totalitarian Vegas.

Totalitarian Vegas, lol! (Las Vegas has its own totalitarianism.)
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Shanghaiski on May 22, 2013, 07:41:27 PM
Reductio ad dictatorum  ::)

Reductio ad latinum.

(Probably didn't get the grammar right.)
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: orthonorm on May 22, 2013, 08:08:55 PM
When all else fails, bring on the Nazis. Yuck.

I'm sorry, but they did have some of the best parades.

Absolutely; however, as I keep pointing out around here, all parades are gay. The homoeroticism of the nazi public demonstrations will never surpassed by another people.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Gunnarr on May 24, 2013, 02:27:41 AM
When all else fails, bring on the Nazis. Yuck.

I'm sorry, but they did have some of the best parades.

Absolutely; however, as I keep pointing out around here, all parades are gay. The homoeroticism of the nazi public demonstrations will never surpassed by another people.

What... well, I am sure the supposed homoerotic nazi parades were surpassed in the gay parades which have very closely naked men dancing all over.

but how are all parades gay? i do not understand.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Gunnarr on May 24, 2013, 02:28:55 AM
http://www.rferl.org/content/georgia-orthodox-priests-antigay-violence/24995118.html

Two clergy, and two other people, have been fined for hooliganism $61 dollars

Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Iconodule on May 24, 2013, 07:59:03 AM
When all else fails, bring on the Nazis. Yuck.

I'm sorry, but they did have some of the best parades.

Absolutely; however, as I keep pointing out around here, all parades are gay. The homoeroticism of the nazi public demonstrations will never surpassed by another people.

What... well, I am sure the supposed homoerotic nazi parades were surpassed in the gay parades which have very closely naked men dancing all over.

You ever notice how the scariest horror movies are the ones that show you the least?
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Orthodox11 on May 24, 2013, 10:15:07 AM
http://www.rferl.org/content/georgia-orthodox-priests-antigay-violence/24995118.html

Two clergy, and two other people, have been fined for hooliganism $61 dollars

A Georgian speaker will have to confirm the accuracy of Google Translate here, but I was under the impression the two clergy were facing two years in prison:
http://pirveliradio.ge/index.php?newsid=3421#

The article you cited said four men were fined $61 and doesn't say that included the two clerics.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: ialmisry on May 24, 2013, 10:24:24 AM
Christ is risen!
Why? It's true. Every gay manifestation in Eastern Europe I've heard ends up being attacked by violent "religious" mob. I would be surprised if for once it wasn't.

Perhaps it's a post-Soviet phenomenon rather than an Orthodox one?

That might be. Mykonos in Greece was, according to the Lonely Planet guide, the biggest gay tourist destination in Europe until it was supplanted by some place in Spain.
Mallorca, where hedonism of all sorts is promoted.  In such places gayism thrives.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Santagranddad on May 24, 2013, 10:48:31 AM
Christ is risen!
Why? It's true. Every gay manifestation in Eastern Europe I've heard ends up being attacked by violent "religious" mob. I would be surprised if for once it wasn't.

Perhaps it's a post-Soviet phenomenon rather than an Orthodox one?

That might be. Mykonos in Greece was, according to the Lonely Planet guide, the biggest gay tourist destination in Europe until it was supplanted by some place in Spain.
Mallorca, where hedonism of all sorts is promoted.  In such places gayism thrives.

Mykonos is literally next door to Tinos (Sometimes referred to as Greece's Lourdes). I have visited Tinos many times and lived there for a period. Now I have never ever heard of any attack on any of it's hedonistic tourists or long stayers. The evidence might suggest the ugly phenomena of so-called Gay bashing may be a post Soviet one.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: ialmisry on May 24, 2013, 11:09:53 AM
Christ est resucite!

For comparison:
Quote
Lots of people right around the world were very surprised that such huge number of people in France, over 1 million, took to the streets to protest against redefining marriage. How did you manage to unite such a diverse range of people in defending traditional marriage?

Yeah. It is a bit of a mystery, obviously. A bit of a miracle! We were surprised as well! The leaders of the movement have been careful about trying to control the messages going out from the movement. They have been quite strict, I would say. We’ve focussed on the rights of children. No religious arguments. Trying to attract people from every religion or none. No political arguments. We’re not against the president or the government, just against the bill, so we’ve been joined by people who even voted for Hollande.  Also, we’ve not made any negative arguments against homosexuality, so we’ve avoided being treated as “homophobic”. Non-violent, non-aggressive, very positive, happy movement. With the economic crisis, the country is a bit depressed, so we wanted a more positive movement, with funny and catchy slogans, which made the people want to come and join us, having a good time! So not your usual angry protest. So we’ve succeeded in getting people from a lot of different backgrounds.
http://www.lifesitenews.com/news/french-marriage-activists-vow-to-fight-on
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Gunnarr on May 25, 2013, 12:06:02 AM
http://www.rferl.org/content/georgia-orthodox-priests-antigay-violence/24995118.html

Two clergy, and two other people, have been fined for hooliganism $61 dollars

A Georgian speaker will have to confirm the accuracy of Google Translate here, but I was under the impression the two clergy were facing two years in prison:
http://pirveliradio.ge/index.php?newsid=3421#

The article you cited said four men were fined $61 and doesn't say that included the two clerics.

I think you are right, i just assumed 2 of the four charged were the clergy in the title

but i can no longer modify the post

thank you for the correction
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: William on May 25, 2013, 05:47:44 AM
Keepin' it classy as always.

You've posted some comparisons that would put Godwin to shame.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: Iconodule on May 25, 2013, 09:46:35 AM
Keepin' it classy as always.

You've posted some comparisons that would put Godwin to shame.

That sounds suspiciously like something Hitler would say.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: orthonorm on May 25, 2013, 11:04:56 AM
Keepin' it classy as always.

You've posted some comparisons that would put Godwin to shame.

That sounds suspiciously like something Hitler would say.

.sig worthy!!!!!!!

That requires some depth, to get funny outta Hitler still.
Title: Re: Patriarch Ilia II calls for ban on "gay rights march" "Gay-Rights Rally"
Post by: orthonorm on May 25, 2013, 11:07:04 AM
Because, since they cannot acknowledge a problem with themselves, the problem therefore must lie with society. Therefore, the society must be change. Then, supposedly, they will stop killing themselves .

Dude, I know you can do better than this. Really this sorta beneath you. Don't start wallowing in our filth.

You bat like .825 around here.